If Matt Donahue hadn’t found that motel bed in Brewer so darn comfortable, Mike Thurston’s half-court buzzer-beater to lift the Caribou Vikings to the 1969 Maine Class LL boys basketball championship over the Westbrook Blue Blazes may have never been possible.
“The Shot Heard ‘Round the State,” as the 45-foot desperation heave was soon known, capped a late comeback for the Vikings on that Saturday night 40 years ago, giving them a 65-63 victory on March 8, 1969 at the Mecca of Maine high school basketball, the Bangor Auditorium. Thurston immediately became the hero of Aroostook County, his name forever a part of Maine hoops lore.
Donahue, a Westbrook junior at the time, went on to write the Blazes’ scoring record books. His 1,513 career points remain the most in school history. He scored 57 points in a legendary effort his senior year against Deering, well before the advent of the 3-point arc.
Sure, he finished with a game-high 26 points against Caribou, but, as he remembers it, that nice mattress with those clean sheets provided him with the best pre-game nap of his life, leaving him lethargic for the first half of the game.
“I fell asleep before the game and all of a sudden, it seemed like there were seven people in my room,” said Donahue, 57, an artist who lives and paints in South Portland. “They’re like, ‘Let’s go, hurry up.’ And I’m like, ‘What’s going on?’ They said, ‘We’re on our way to the game.’ I threw my clothes on and we went to the game and I think it was probably sometime in the third quarter that I finally woke up. Through warm-ups and the first half, I’m just going through the motions. I have no idea what’s going on. I had 26 points and that may sound good, but I should have had like 40.”
Don Douglas, a senior starter and second-leading scorer for the Blue Blazes who also doubled as the team’s beat writer for the American Journal, put it this way in his story in the March 12, 1969 issue of the newspaper: “Indomitable scoring wizard Matt Donahue was contained in the early going but inevitably found his superb scoring touch in the last half and actually sparked a third-quarter rally which saw Westbrook pull away to its largest bulge 39-30. The record-breaking scoring ace and Vinall trophy winner wound up a magnificent junior season with a game-high 26 points.”
Vikings rally
Westbrook still led by eight midway through the fourth quarter, but Caribou put together a furious rally and tied the game on a three-point play with 10 seconds left. The Blazes had the ball with a chance to win.
“I knew they were going to press,” said longtime Westbrook coach Bill Folsom, 81, who is retired and living in Florida. “We set up a press breaker and took it to the other end of the court in about four seconds.”
Douglas had the ball and an open look at the hoop.
“I took a shot from between the foul line and the top of the key,” said Douglas, 58, who is an attorney and owns Douglas Title Company in Yarmouth with his wife, Abigail. “It hit off the back rim. That was with less than five seconds to go in a tie game. We thought it was for the win, or we’d go to overtime.”
The rebound bounced to the corner where Caribou’s Pete Curran snagged it and threw an outlet pass to Thurston, who was clapping for the ball with the final seconds ticking away.
“Much to his credit, he saw me and made a nice outlet pass,” said Thurston, 57, a physical education teacher at Old Town Elementary School for the past 35 years. “I took two or three dribbles then took the old two-hand set shot from way back in the early days of basketball. I remember thinking on the way that if this thing is long enough, if it’s got legs, it could be good.”
Douglas, who finished with 12 points, said he was the closest defender to Thurston when he released the shot.
“We both watched it together,” said Douglas, also Westbrook’s valedictorian and a minor league baseball player in the Chicago Cubs organization for a couple seasons after graduating from Amherst College.
“I don’t think I said anything to him afterward. He was mobbed immediately and I was ready to crawl into a hole somewhere.”
Pandemonium ensues
As soon as Thurston released the shot, the referee signaled that the shot was in the air before time expired. He didn’t consult with the clock operator before declaring the shot was good.
“I checked with the clock operator and he threw his hands in the air and said he didn’t know,” Folsom said. “Pandemonium took hold and the game was over.”
Reflecting back, Folsom said he would have instructed his players to hold for the last shot, but he figured it would have taken longer than four seconds to get the ball up the court against the Caribou pressure. Donahue said the Blazes did everything right in the final seconds.
“Donny taking that last shot, that’s exactly what he should have done,” Donahue said. “No one expected this Thurston kid to throw it in from 45 feet.
“I remember looking up at the ball, because I was pretty close to him, and thinking, ‘That looks pretty decent to me.’ When that thing went through I thought, ‘Wow. That’s kind of cool.'”
The Vikings faithful – making up more than half of the nearly 6,000 fans in attendance – poured onto the court.
“It literally was a fairy tale, right out of the celluloid library of dream shots,” Douglas said. “He shot his way into basketball immortality with that.”
“The Caribou crowd went absolutely berserk,” Thurston said. “We were mobbed. There couldn’t have been more than 25 people left in the town. The place was just rocked from the floor to the very top of the auditorium.”
Thurston didn’t notice the Blazes fans at the time, but later received a packet of photos from the game containing an unforgettable shot of the Westbrook crowd.
“Everybody on their feet, just stunned,” Thurston said. “Nobody was talking. Mouths were open.”
‘What a great shot’
Once the mayhem subsided enough, the players lined up to shake hands. Thurston said much of the post-game jubilation is a blur, but one memory stands out – Donahue’s congratulations.
“I remember coming specifically to Matt, and Matt shaking my hand and saying, ‘What a great shot,'” Thurston said.
As the Vikings cut down the nets and were presented with the Gold Ball, the Westbrook players got little consolation from their runner-up medals and plaque.
“We were absolutely devastated, completely devastated by the loss,” Douglas said. “We felt it was our game to win and that we let the great city of Westbrook down.”
Donahue doesn’t remember feeling the pain that he saw many of his teammates experiencing. To him, it was just another game. He loved basketball – lived and breathed the game, going on to star at the University of Southern Maine, where he still holds many scoring records – but was never overly affected by winning and losing, even though he thought the loss fell on him.
“When anybody shoots the ball as much as I did, that was a big part of the offense. You’re responsible for winning or losing,” Donahue said. “The games I played up to the old Cumberland Gym were as important to me, and in some ways were more fun, than playing in front of thousands of people. It was just a game. It could be an important game, a tournament game and when the game was over, I was just ready to take my shower and move on. I would see how upset other people were and try to make it look like I was a little upset.”
The charge that was never called
Whether or not Thurston actually got the shot off in time quickly became irrelevant. Folsom, who was up and getting ready for the overtime that never was when the shot went in, said that wasn’t even the most controversial call in the game’s final 10 seconds. To this day, he believes the three-point play that tied the game should never have counted.
Iconic Portland Press Herald sportswriter Dick Doyle’s account of the play went like this: “Leading up to the dramatic climax, Caribou gained a tie with 10 seconds remaining as rugged Mike Kelley forced a foul while dunking in a followup under great defensive pressure. Mike converted the foul shot to complete the three-point play and tie the ball game.”
That’s not quite the way Folsom remembers it. “Kelley, their big guy, knocked down about three people and put the ball in the basket and got a free throw,” Folsom said. “We were still three points up before that slam-bam three-point play. I’m certain that was a charge that was never called. We weren’t about to foul anybody, being three points ahead. We were backing away from him and he ran right over us and put it in. The ref gave him a free throw and it tied the game.”
Kelley, an All-State player, finished with 13 points. Thurston had 10. Quentin Blackstone led the Vikings with a career-high 24 points, keeping his team in the game and making Thurston’s heroics possible.
Aroostook legend
If that charge had been called, if Donahue had found his groove a bit earlier, if Douglas’ final jump shot had found the net, if the referee ruled the game was going to overtime, Thurston’s shot never would have mattered. It certainly wouldn’t be conversation fodder 40 years later and “Half-court” Thurston would never have been recognized as one of the greatest 50 Maine sports figures of the 20th century in Sports Illustrated’s Dec. 27, 1999 issue.
But the shot was good. Forgotten was the fact that Thurston struggled shooting the ball against the tough defense of Douglas, scoring well below his season average.
“If we had won that game, nobody would have ever cared about that again,” Donahue said. “That kid throwing the ball in changed everything up in Caribou. It’s a game that nobody has ever forgotten”
“It has become part of the mythology of Maine high school basketball,” Douglas said. “It’s no question he’s a mythic figure in Aroostook County to this day.”
Westbrook High athletic director Todd Sampson, who did his student teaching at Caribou High School in 1994, can confirm Thurston’s celebrity status in “The County”. “I probably heard the story 30 times about ‘The Shot Heard ‘Round the State.’ I didn’t know he made it against Westbrook.”
The missing banner
The passage of time has made the loss more bearable for Douglas, though he still ponders what could have been every time he walks into Warren Centennial Gymnasium.
“Even now when I go to Westbrook basketball games and see the banners up in the gym, our 1969 Western Maine champs banner – just to look at that brings back that stab that says, ‘Yeah there should have been another state championship banner next to the ’72 and ’75 championships,'” Douglas said.
“You get older and you get perspective. You realize you were lucky to have played in a game like that and had that experience, and to have played in a city like Westbrook that was absolutely, 100 percent committed to basketball. It was a time when boys high school basketball was the king sport in the winter.”
The Blazes spent the night following the game at the motel with the comfortable beds. The next morning, Folsom took the team to church before the long bus ride home.
When the bus got off at Exit 8, there was a throng of supporters there to greet it.
“At that point we were still absolutely crushed, absolutely despondent,” Douglas said. “The city of Westbrook still loved us, but we had no sense of that. Coach Folsom pushed Danny Randall and myself – we were the co-captains – up to the front of the bus so the fans could see us. I think back to that and think of what a mature thing it was for our coach to do. As kids, we had no idea that we should have had a responsibility to acknowledge the fans.”
Folsom, a member of the Maine Sports Hall of Fame, coached Westbrook for 19 years, winning 273 games and two state championships between 1961 and 1980. He was the Westbrook athletic director from 1980 until he retired to Florida in 1987. He still returns to Maine in the summer and he still remembers calling his captains to the front of the bus.
“There were hordes of people there,” Folsom said. “The bus just had to crawl along. The people were looking to greet the team, not me. I always sat at the front of the bus, so I got out of the way so the kids could enjoy it all. It was a fantastic reception. It had the band and everything there. After losing, it really gave them a lift, I think.”
Westbrook Highhat makes the game one of the most memorable in Maine basketball history.
The 1969 Westbrook High boys basketball team. Front row (l to r): Eddie St. Cyr, Chris Ham, Danny Randall, Don Douglas, Jeff Daley, Rick Gieringer. Second row: coach Bill Folsom, Matt Donahue, Paul Lawrence, Jeff Lee, Steve Emery, Al Hall, Kirk Flaherty, manager Gary Sanborn.
Comments are no longer available on this story