The planning boards from Cape Elizabeth and South Portland will begin collaborating on two issues that are of interest to both: development on their shared border and improvements to the water quality of Trout Brook, which runs through both municipalities.
These agreements were made at a joint planning board meeting held on April 26, which was suggested by Cape Elizabeth Town Manager Mike McGovern in January. In a letter to South Portland Town Manager Ted Jankowski, McGovern said, it was “time to consider the cooperative arrangements we now enjoy and the potential for additional relationships.”
A rift between the boards began in 2002 when plans for Blueberry Ridge, a subdivision bordering South Portland, came to the Cape Elizabeth Planning Board. Despite efforts by South Portland to prevent development, the subdivision was built. Due to increased traffic on South Portland roads from residents of Blueberry Ridge, the South Portland City Council voted in February to erect a physical barrier on the border of South Portland and Cape Elizabeth.
“The recent controversy over Blueberry Ridge had not been easy for either community,” McGovern said in the letter. “It strikes me that it would be very beneficial for both Planning Boards to have a joint workshop in the first quarter of 2007 to look at the development potential in the are and to discuss protocols that might be considered should a proposal or proposals be submitted that would impact both communities,” he said.
At the meeting on Thursday, South Portland Planning Board Chairman Rob Schreiber said, “This is a great occasion for both boards to be together.”
There were a few light-hearted references to the recent dispute between the boards about the shared border on Edgewood Road, an issue that Tex Haeuser, South Portland’s city planner, said was “hopefully on its way to getting settled.” Cape Elizabeth Planning Board Vice Chairman Peter Hatem, Schreiber, Haeuser and Maureen O’Meara, Cape Elizabeth town planner, all met for lunch before the meeting and decided that the joint meeting with the rest of the boards would be
“absolutely forward-looking.”
Together, three members of the Cape Elizabeth planning board and seven from South Portland took a look at a map of the border between the city and the town.
“The map represents a major step forward in, if not regional planning, multi-community planning,” said Haeuser.
O’Meara and Haeuser lead a discussion about “hot spots” of the border and discussed the future of the undeveloped land on each side of the line.
South Portland planning board member Don Russell said he respected Cape Elizabeth for the town’s effort to preserve open spaces and would like to see South Portland try to do more of the same.
“It’s one of the reasons I’m on the board,” he said.
Russell said that he views Cape’s approach to land conservation as proactive, while he considers South Portland to have been reactive in the past – a trend he’s been trying to change. “We’re hopefully on the path back,” he said.
Though O’Meara said that the town has had a lot of recent success in conserving land, she acknowledged that South Portland cannot be expected to preserve as much as the town.
“You have urban issues and urban pressures that Cape Elizabeth doesn’t have,” she said.
O’Meara did suggest a strategy that has worked for Cape Elizabeth – to cooperate with developers by asking for their help in preserving open spaces while allowing them to develop in other parts of town. O’Meara said that land preservation can be in the interest of the developer, too. “They’ve started to market open space as an amenity,” she said.
Schreiber also reminded the boards that even though South Portland has lost a lot of open space, the city has other natural resources.
“We do have a lot of access to the water,” he said.
The boards discussed potential issues that would arise if development began to occur land that abutted another open space across the town line. Schreiber suggested that whenever a project like that comes up, the boards would sit down and have a workshop.
Because South Portland’s board meets every second and fourth Tuesday of the month and Cape Elizabeth meets on the first and third Tuesday, they decided that they would hold the workshops at the beginning of regular meetings, hosted by the town that was considering the project.
With that plan in place, the boards began a discussion about the Trout Brook watershed, 55 percent of which runs through Cape Elizabeth and the rest through South Portland. O’Meara presented information on the results of water samplings that have been taken from the brook. The samples show that neither town nor city is meeting the requirements of its classification for water quality standards.
Both planning boards decided this was an issue they would like to look further into, and they would like to do it together, which Steve Puleo, South Portland community planner, said would be a “unique” collaboration. They decided that they would move forward on the project by having Haeuser and O’Meara put together a joint resolution for the two communities with the hope that the statement would incite support from the public. “We’ll have one ready for you soon,” Haeuser said.
The meeting ended with a discussion about how to continue the collaborative relationship that between the two boards.
“There’s been a lot of energy tonight,” Schrieber said.
The planners recommended that the next meeting between the boards be driven by a need to discuss either new development or the Trout Brook resolution, whichever comes up first. Haeuser suggested that an opportunity for the public to address the boards should be included in the next meeting.
“I think what really came out of this is a mutual understanding of the kind of issues that could come out of both boards,” Puleo said.
Comments are no longer available on this story