4 min read

In what she described as a “very unusual” move, District Attorney Stephanie Anderson held a press conference Thursday afternoon to explain her decision not to seek criminal charges against 10 seniors who vandalized Cape Elizabeth High School March 24.

In her comments, Anderson openly challenged school officials’ descriptions of the vandalism and estimates of the cost of repairs, saying estimates putting the damage at $15,000 or more were “not really true.”

She described the seniors’ escapades as “shenanigans” and a “senior prank.”

Anderson said and that the seniors apparently went out of their way not to damage the building.

Anderson said she has offered all 10 teens the opportunity to sign a contract with her office under which they will do community service, abstain from alcohol, drugs and illegal activities, and pay about $1,400 restitution each to the school district.

The teens have until Friday to sign the contract, which Anderson provided to them during a meeting with the teens, their parents, their attorneys and school officials on Monday.

Advertisement

Anderson said she had originally thought she would be pursuing criminal charges against the teens, based on school officials comments as reported in the media immediately after the vandalism. School officials reported thousands of dollars of damage to ceiling tiles, broken furniture, obscene and profane graffiti on walls, and peanut butter smeared on doorknobs. Officials closed the school for a day to repair the vandalism, and students and teachers made up the time the following Saturday.

The students were suspended for 13 days by the school board, banned from team sports and lost all senior privileges. They will be allowed to graduate with the class.

Anderson said the damage described by school officials in the media, was far beyond what actually occurred.

“When I first heard about this case, I was pretty angry because I was unfettered by these facts,” she said. “I was going to put this evidence in to the grand jury and indict these kids.”

Anderson said she learned in investigating the incident that all of the graffiti had been written in erasable marker on whiteboards, and that while it was inappropriate, “I’ve seen a lot worse, I’ll tell you.”

She also said the students had apparently taken great care not to damage ceiling tiles or the support structure when they removed them and stacked them neatly in from of doorways.

Advertisement

“Most of them were not damaged. Some of them were damaged,” she said. “The superintendent or someone decided that all of the ceiling tiles would be replaced, damaged or not.”

She passed around photos of the stacked ceiling tiles and other acts of vandalism in an attempt to demonstrate that it was not as severe as had been described. Police and school officials have refused to provide photos to the media.

In a telephone interview immediately after the press conference, Superintendent Alan Hawkins said he could not respond specifically to Anderson’s comments at the press conference because he had not been there, but that school officials felt it was appropriate to replace all the ceiling tiles.

“I wasn’t there. What I can say to you is that there was damage, there were tiles piled up etc.,” he said. “To me, vandalism is defined when damage is done to the physical (plant) of the school.”

Anderson also quoted a letter from a “building manager” at the school who wrote to her that the tiles were “carefully removed,” that there was not a piece of the supporting gridwork “out of place,” and that it would have taken “a considerable amount of effort to remove the tiles without damaging the gridwork.”

“Some of the tiles were damaged, not all of them, but it was the school’s decision to replace all of them,” she said. She said replacing all the tiles cost $4,000, replacing a desk that appeared to have minor damage from someone standing on it cost $600, and replacing two other pieces of furniture with mild damage cost $3,000.

Advertisement

Asked whether she felt school officials misrepresented the damage, Anderson replied, “I think I’ve already commented on what actually happened there. Draw your own conclusions.”

“These kids went in and fooled around and did some damage,” she said. “… It was okay in my view to mess up their lives for the next few months, but I did not want to ruin their futures.”

Anderson said she decided to hold the press conference to quell media speculation and inaccuracies, despite her general policy of not commenting on a case until after it has been resolved.

“What’s unusual is that I’m talking about it at this point in time,” she said. “I figured you guys were going to, like, make it up.”

She said she expects a “firestorm of criticism” from people who think the Cape Elizabeth students were treated with unfair leniency, but that “reasonable people can disagree.”

She also pledged that future “senior pranks” will not be taken lightly by her office.

“The days of senior pranks are gone,” she said. “There will be no senior pranks tolerated. Any other pranks … If your names come across my desk, it’s not going to look like this.”

In an interview after the press conference, Hawkins said he felt Anderson’s resolution was appropriate. He said he believed media accounts were inaccurate and exaggerated, “without question,” and that press accounts had been “very destructive” to the community.

He also said he felt he was “very definitely supported in the board” in his handling of the vandalism.

Comments are no longer available on this story