6 min read

With just two weeks left before the November general election, Scarborough voters must decide how to vote on a polarizing proposal for a 535-acre development around the Scarborough Downs horse racetrack that includes slot machines.

Scarborough voters defeated a smaller racino proposal in 2002, but the scope of the proposed $200 million Scarborough Village project makes it either more appealing or more offensive, depending on whom you ask. Supporters cite its potential to bring in $8 million of annual municipal revenues and boost the foundering harness-racing industry by bringing in more tourists and increasing purses at the Downs. Detractors have said they don’t want more gambling in town and that the latest concept was brought along too quickly for the town to evaluate it properly.

The issue has even caused a contentious split among town leaders and brought outside backing for publicity campaigns from heavy hitters in Maine’s wager wars, such as Penn National Gaming Inc. and CasinosNO!

“Somebody had to say something,” said Mark Maroon, a former town councilor and outspoken opponent of Connecticut developer Gene Beaudoin’s current proposal. “Saving Our Scarborough has been resurrected.”

Saving Our Scarborough, a local citizens’ group, helped derail the 2002 racino initiative, but it may have met its match.

Beaudoin, who brought the Cabela’s retail project to the Haigis Parkway area, aims to create a mixed-use development with an “integrated downtown” or “Main Street” component comprising businesses, the slot-machine parlor, some residences and a revitalized racetrack.

Advertisement

Beaudoin said Friday the racino remains integral to his plans for two reasons – it would support Scarborough Downs owner Sharon Terry’s efforts to operate the track at a profit, and it would bring in sufficient revenue to pay for major infrastructure work necessary to develop the site.

“Sharon Terry views the racino as the mechanism by which she can keep harness racing alive,” said Beaudoin.

Beaudoin and Kathryn Rolston, a former Downs spokeswoman now working on an independent contractor basis as a slot-machine advocate for Penn National have enlisted Scarborough horse farmers Tim and Sarah Nehila in support of the racino. The Nehilas and other residents were paid $7 dollars per signature to gather names for the petition that successfully put the racino issue on the 2008 ballot. The referendum would allow “operation of slot machines at a commercial racetrack” in the B-2 zone with certain stipulations, including the $8 million in annual town revenue.

At their farm Sunday, Sarah Nehila described raising racehorses as an expensive and time-consuming venture, but one the family hoped to continue at their farm.

“We built it in ’96, but it was my great-grandparents’ land,” said Nehila about the farm.

Rolston speculated that Terry’s devotion to preserving harness racing could eventually force her to move the track out of Scarborough if racino support were not forthcoming. She offered no specific alternative.

Advertisement

Beaudoin estimated that about $20 million of utilities improvements and other site preparations, roughly 10 percent of the total project cost, would be necessary. Slot machines would up the ante, so to speak, and provide enough money for what he called massing, or having a large enough project to succeed.

“Massing is the key,” said Beaudoin. The slots parlor would cover less than one-fifth of 1 percent of the whole development site, he noted, but the racino revenue would be “the switch that turns it on.”

According to Beaudoin, the Scarborough Village Partnership political action committee intends to submit a report by Oct. 24 with expanded details of its contributions and expenditures. PACs are required to file with the state if they raise or spend more than $1,500. He noted that CasinosNO!, the statewide political action committee organized against larger casino proposals around Maine, was now running anti-racino ads targeted at Scarborough Village on cable television. Rolston said Sunday that the slot-machine supporters would soon purchase and run their own ads.

A document filed at the Scarborough town clerk’s office on Sept. 26 indicated that funding for the pro-slots campaign had thus far been provided by Penn National and Beaudoin, but it contained few other details.

Dennis Bailey, CasinosNO! executive director, confirmed Friday that his group bought the new anti-racino ad and had also hired a field organizer in Scarborough.

“We’re helping them out down there,” he said.

Advertisement

According to Bailey, opponents mishandled the ballot issue that allowed Penn National to open Hollywood Slots in Bangor several years ago because “nobody really realized that that meant a full-blown racino year round,” and he hopes to avoid inattention to the current Scarborough situation.

The only two listed contributors to CasinosNO! during September, according to its PAC report, were two Scarborough-area residents. Merton Henry, of Scarborough, gave $200, and Richard Kurtz, of Cape Elizabeth, donated $10,000. Henry and Kurtz, however, have long been involved in efforts to stop Maine casinos, said Bailey.

Maroon and Bailey each believe that Scarborough Town Council Chairman Jeffrey Messer has crossed over into supporting Scarborough Village as proposed, but Messer insisted on Sunday that he remains officially neutral and merely wanted the best facts put before the public. Messer’s 30-minute presentation at the Oct. 15 Town Council meeting focused almost entirely on the racino’s potential benefits and refuting Maroon’s concerns.

Messer estimated that of the $8 million in annual town revenues, $1.5 million would come from real estate taxes, $500,000 from personal property taxes and the balance from the gaming revenue. During the presentation, Messer also slammed the accuracy of some of Maroon’s claims about community problems with slot machines, calling them “scare tactics” that were “disgusting” or “inflammatory.”

Messer said Sunday that his position had “evolved” after reviewing project details and seeing opponents become too “emotional,” and that voters shouldn’t ignore the racino’s ability to help build capital improvement projects such as an intermediate school, a public safety building and a recreation center.

“This project could pay for all of those things and more and still lower taxes,” Beaudoin said.

Advertisement

“I’m not endorsing the proposal outright,” said Messer, who will step down from Town Council next month due to term limits. “There’s plenty of reasons if people want to vote no,” he acknowledged, while disagreeing with Maroon’s statistics about social costs of gaming facilities.

“A racino doesn’t bring quality of life, it doesn’t bring good-paying jobs … based on our combined experience, our combined research,” countered Maroon.

Even if a slot parlor doesn’t drive up the measurable costs of enforcing drunken-driving and petty-crime laws, he added, “There’s a big difference between the social costs and the police costs of something.”

If Messer and Maroon agree on anything, it might be that preserving harness racing is not one of their goals.

“Is it the town’s job to help someone who has a horse racing business?” asked Maroon rhetorically.

“I don’t really care about harness racing,” said Messer. “I didn’t (in 2002), and I don’t now.”

Advertisement

Messer noted that the Maine State Lottery and bingo are existing forms of gambling, and that because of the racetrack, “Scarborough was the only town in Maine that allowed gambling for a long time.”

He emphasized that the racino, even if approved by Scarborough voters, would then have to obtain approval from the governor and the state Legislature. Town councilors would then negotiate a host agreement with the developers before putting that agreement before voters via a second referendum. Messer also stressed that he inserted language into a motion passed by the Town Council earlier this month to ensure a second round of voter approval.

“Under state law, the town can ask for as much as it wants,” acknowledged Beaudoin.

But Maroon believes Beaudoin has been inflexible about including slot machines in the development by saying that without the gaming component, no project would get built, a position he likened to drawing a line in the sand.

Comments are no longer available on this story