2 min read

Cape Elizabeth will hold a public hearing Sept. 14 to discuss what to do about the Goddard Mansion ruin in Fort Williams Park.

The Town Council voted unanimously Monday night to have the hearing. There was no discussion of the issue at the meeting.

In April, the Fort Williams Advisory Commission recommended that the town discontinue efforts to sustain the Goddard Mansion as it now stands.

The commission wants the town to appropriate $6,000 from the park’s capital fund to fence off areas surrounding the carriage house and connecting walls, to protect the public. It is asking that deterioration of the existing walls be allowed to continue.

In contrast, a recent study of the mansion, included in a broader study of Fort Williams Park projects by Renner/Woodworth Architects Inc., listed alternatives for the Goddard Mansion that ranged from full structural repair to complete demolition. Renner/Woodworth concluded repair would cost about $631,000 and demolition would cost about $65,000.

“We want to give the public an opportunity to discuss this before the council makes a decision,” Town Council Chairman James Rowe said.

The Sept. 14 meeting will be at 7:30 p.m. An official agenda has not been set.

Col. John Goddard, colonel of the First Maine Cavalry, built the mansion in 1853 with 2-foot-thick stone masonry walls. The roof and interior walls were made of wood.

The mansion became part of Fort Williams and was used to house noncommissioned officers. It became Cape Elizabeth’s property with the town’s purchase of Fort Williams in 1964. In 1981, deterioration and vandalism led the local Fire Department to conduct a controlled burn of the mansion, and the basement was filled in to allow visitors access to what remained of the mansion.

Comments are no longer available on this story