SCARBOROUGH – The Scarborough Town Council will look to the school board for guidance before deciding what number to take to voters in a June 11 re-try of the education budget, turned down by residents at a May 14 referendum.
At a council finance committee meeting Wednesday morning, panel members Judy Roy and Jessica Holbrook asked the school board to come back with examples of where money would come from at various levels of funding cuts.
“The vibes are 3 percent at least, that’s what I’m hearing [from other councilors],” said Roy, speaking as chairwoman of the finance committee.
That percentage is the increase in spending from the current budget, calculated to include food services. The increase approved by the council was 4.01 percent. However, the $38.86 million budget sent to voters only included contribution to meals, otherwise supported by sales and subsidies, from the school’s operating budget, for a 3.85 percent increase.
Voters rejected that budget 643-898, with 929 of them, or 60.8 percent, checking a box that called the proposal “too high.”
According to Superintendent George Entwistle, the school board finance committee continues to plug away at possible reductions, as it has since the May 14 vote. The full board will adopt on a new budget proposal at a special meeting, now set for 6 p.m. on Thursday, May 23, at town hall.
The Town Council will formally receive that proposal at a special meeting of its own on May 29. It will then conduct a public hearing and second reading on the school budget at its June 5 regular meeting, at which time councilors are expected to vote on a new bottom line.
If that happens, absentee ballots for the June 11 vote will be available at town hall June 6.
According to Roy, getting to the council’s 3 percent growth target on the full budget including food service will mean shaving $391,400.
However, the newest member of the finance committee, Councilor Ed Blaise, said cuts need to be far deeper, and should come from the municipal side of the ledger, as well as the school side.
“It really doesn’t have anything to do with the school budget,” he said. “People voted because their taxes are too high. I think we have to agree, that’s really what they were telling us.”
Blaise has previously noted that property taxes in Scarborough have gone up 22.6 percent in the last four years, while Councilor James Benedict has publicly complained that his own tax bill has shot up 100 percent since 2001, when he moved to town.
And, although the council met its goal of a 3 percent total spending increase on all three legs of the annual budget, including Cumberland County taxes as well as school and municipal operations, the loss of state subsidy dollars means tax bills are expected to shoot up 7.9 percent.
“Yes, the increases are horrifying,” said Holbrook, “but it all relates directly to what we’ve lost.”
Perhaps even more horrifying, depending on what happens over the next month in the state Legislature, the 2013-2014 municipal budget already adopted by the Town Council does not account for the proposed elimination of state revenue sharing, which could sap $1.81 million from Scarborough coffers.
“The real question is, what do we feel is a reasonable increase in taxes for the townspeople to accept?” asked Blaise.
The freshman councilor then suggested a 4 percent tax increase, which would mean carving out $2 million, an amount Blaise said should be divvied on a 60/40 split. That, he said, would mean taking $1.2 million from the school department and $800,000 from the municipal budget.
Roy, however, would have none of it.
“At this point in the proceedings we are not asked to readdress the town budget,” she said. “That’s why we have a town council. If we put the town budget out to the public the same kind of thing might happen.”
Pointing out the difference between the town council form of government, in which an elected body adopts the annual budget, and the selectboard form, in which the people are the legislative body and must approve spending at an annual town meeting, Roy said turnout often hinges on interest groups.
In the past, the rap has been that the school budget vote is a cakewalk because of the number of school employees, and their family members, who turn out for the validation effort. The conventional wisdom this year, however, is that those voters got swamped by senior citizens on fixed incomes and beachfront residents upset over this year’s round of property reassessments.
The 1,541-person turnout May 14 was a record for a year in which the school validation vote was the only item on the ballot. However, Town Clerk Tody Justice has pegged that figure at just 10 percent of registered voters.
“Yes, the vote sent a clear message,” said Roy, “but does it really represent the general populace?”
Meanwhile, Holbrook seemed to straddle a line somewhere between positions staked out by Blaise and Roy.
“It’s that sinking affect where you just are getting hit at every angle. I think there were a lot of people voting their pocket books,” she said, appearing to side with Blaise.
“But you can’t take $1 million or $2 million out of the school and think you’d even have a school left at that point,” she said, leaning more toward Roy, who openly balked at Blaise’s bottom line, in addition to his advice to also amend the municipal budget.
Still, Blaise said a $391,400 cut in school spending would only reduce the coming tax increase from 7.9 percent to 7.1 percent.
“That’s kind of an insult to the intelligence of the voters,” he said. “They did not turn this thing down because of 8/10ths of 1 percent.”
Town Manager Tom Hall agreed with Blaise that something needs to be done about spending over the long term, but seemed to warn the finance committee away from making Draconian cuts this season.
“We can nibble around the edges, but it’s not sustainable, the path we are one,” he said. “We need some structural changes, but it should not be reached just by massive cuts to meet a target.”
Chris Caiazzo, chairman of the school board finance committee, said progress might be made next year with earlier and more frequent budget workshops between the school board and the council.
For this year, however, he said his group will have to tread a very careful line in deciding what to cut, and what number to bring back to the council.
“The biggest misconception out there is that the school department is just another municipal department,” he said. “But if you start comparing what teachers do to what public works crews do, it’s not a fair comparison.
“You impact a child this year, that impact is felt thought the whole [educational] process,” said Caiazzo.
If voters reject the school budget a second time, a third vote likely will not happen until after the start of the new fiscal year, July 1. Under state law, the school can then continue to operate, with the town assessing taxpayers for dollar amounts approved last year, until a new budget is adopted.
Comments are no longer available on this story