What do the four following cities have in common? Portland, Maine; Burlington, Vt.; Northampton, Mass., and Cambridge, Mass. They are arguably among the most liberal cities in New England.
And it turns out Scarborough may soon be linked with these four powerhouses of political activism. If the Town Council follows through on Town Manager Tom Hall’s recommendation to sign up for the STAR Communities program for $500 per year, we will have joined that notable group of cities. STAR Communities stands for Sustainability Tools for Assessing and Rating Communities.
The STAR Communities program, based in Washington, D.C., is being portrayed as a way for Scarborough to assess its current livability and set goals for future improvements. Sounds fairly benign on the surface – who doesn’t want a livable town? But when you go to the company’s website (starcommunities.org) and do a bit of research, you will quickly see that it is an agenda-driven organization with a pronounced liberal/progressive slant.
Merely looking at the listing of the 44 ratings categories provides a sense of where the ratings will lead. Among the categories: greenhouse gas mitigation, climate adaptation, waste minimization, quality jobs and living wages, environmental justice, safe communities, green infrastructure and invasive species.
It takes very little imagination to see the type of goals that will need to be set to achieve high scores in the STAR rating system: all-electric town-owned vehicles, a pay-to-throw waste system, a ban on plastic bags and Styrofoam containers, a “livable” minimum wage for the town, perhaps a rent control ordinance and – the gold standard – sanctuary city status.
Am I being too cynical here? Perhaps. But consider just a couple of the funding sources for STAR Communities. The U.S. Green Building Council is one. They couldn’t possibly have a vested financial interest in the program’s goal of “resource efficient buildings,” could they? And the Center for American Progress, according to Wikipedia, “was created in 2003 as a left-leaning alternative to think tanks such as the Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute.”
Is this highly politicized rating system what Scarborough residents really need to determine the town’s future livability goals?
If you are like me and many others, you probably moved to Scarborough because you like its characteristics – nice neighborhoods and neighborliness, amazing natural resources, a strong school system, a modest property tax burden, a somewhat rural feel and the convenience to many of the amenities of the Greater Portland area. In short, you came here because you like Scarborough pretty much the way it is.
So why do town leaders seem so driven to change the basics of life in Scarborough? Sure, improvements may be desirable, but shouldn’t those be identified by the people of Scarborough themselves rather than a seven-person Town Council deciding that a Washington, D.C.-based liberal think tank should set our municipal aspirations?
Personally, I see no need whatsoever to spend even $500 on the introductory level membership in the STARS Communities program. If you want to know how Scarborough residents want to make the town more livable, ask them! Improved communication with the community is one of the Town Council’s main goals this year. If the council would realize that communications is a two-way process – one that involves listening as well as speaking – they may be more successful in achieving the goal.
Here’s a simple suggestion for better understanding Scarborough residents’ satisfaction with the town’s livability and their desires for changes: Prepare a short, unbiased survey on resident satisfaction and let them identify future town goals. Send this out with the tax bills next month; that’s a piece of mail every taxpayer pays attention to.
The results may surprise town leaders. It’s entirely possible that folks in Scarborough would prefer that the Town Council deal with the more mundane issues of traffic on Route 1 and efficient municipal and school operations than the larger issues of social and environmental issues that have historically been dealt with at the state and federal level.
Let’s leave the STARS in the heavens and focus the town’s efforts here on earth.
Steve Hanly is a Scarborough resident. Visit his blog or contact him at www.LookOutScarborough.com.
Comments are no longer available on this story