Pared down from 334 units to 258, a planned “retirement village” off Elmwood Avenue got preliminary, informal approval of the Scarborough Town Council April 10.
Although councilors and neighbors said they were worried about the scale of the project and the traffic it would create in the quiet residential neighborhood, they also said it is inevitable that the parcel will be developed.
“That land will be developed. It’s only a question of when,” Chairman Jeffrey Messer said. He added there’s “no question that this project is going to dwarf the neighborhood.”
The project is expected to increase traffic on Scarborough’s roads by 689 trips a day, according to the developer, and place the demands of 334-plus new residents on all of the town services.
But it won’t produce any children in need of education, and that’s a major plus in Scarborough.
According to the developer, Harvest Development LLC, the project will bring a net increase to town tax revenue of $295,00 annually, while if the land was developed into 90 single-family homes with 1.92 children each, it would cost the town $1.2 million a year.
“You can either have this project or you can have a housing development,” Councilor Richard Sullivan summarized. “I am in favor of this project. I think it’s a real nice-looking project.”
Harvest Development first approached the town in February with its plans for what was formerly farmland in the Green Acres neighborhood, between Route 1 and Route 114. Because the 68-acre property is currently zoned for residential housing on half-acre lots, the developer is requesting that the town create a “contract zone,” or special zoning district, to permit the project to go forward.
That would require town officials to determine that the project is in the best interests of the public.
Contract zones have been instrumental in developing several areas in town that are now major contributors to the town tax base, including the new Cabela’s and the Mercedes Benz and Jaguar dealerships.
After submitting its documents to the town in February, Harvest Development got immediate feedback from some town officials and neighbors that the project was too big and would create too much traffic. On April 10, project manager Owens McCullough of Sebago Technics presented a scaled-back version that decreased the number of units and offered several options for how a three-story, assisted-living facility could be scaled back to better blend in with its surroundings.
McCullough also offered several suggestions for managing traffic, including requiring that employees not cut through residential neighborhoods to get to work. The developer has also offered to put half the land into open space conservation and build new public walking trails.
Some neighbors, however, were still concerned.
Alison Davis, a mother of three pre-schoolers, was uncomfortable with the traffic implications and the sheer size of the project.
“I do still feel that it is too large for our neighborhood,” she said. “The (assisted living facility), the way it looks now, it looks like a hotel, almost.”
Annemarie Silvius wasn’t convinced that the employees wouldn’t cut through residential neighborhoods if they were asked not to.
“It’s absolutely asinine (to think) that public people will not use a public road to get where they need to go,” she said.
Brian Davis, Alison Davis’ brother-in-law, said he fears that the noise from the Intestate 295 connector will increase dramatically once tree clearing begins.
Councilors had their own concerns. Carol Rancourt said she would like to see affordable housing in at least part of the project. Judy Roy said she’d like to see green building practices.
However, all council members voted to encourage Harvest Development to continue with the application process.
“I think this is a good proposal,” Rancourt said. “It’s very difficult to see neighborhoods changing … but they do change. Mine, yours, everyone’s.”
The project will have to go through several more public hearings and get binding approval from both the Planning Board and the Town Council.
Holiday Retirement, the parent of Harvest Development, has constructed more than 300 retirement communities throughout North America, including Sunbury Village in Bangor, The Woods at Canco in Portland and Kittery Point in Kittery.
Comments are no longer available on this story