NAPLES – John Chase, owner of Chase Custom Homes in Windham, is facing stiff fines for his role in the March 22 removal of hundreds of trees and rocks along the shoreline of Long Lake in Naples, a clear-cutting one neighbor described as a “blight on the landscape.”
Although the identity of who excavated the site remains a mystery, Chase is the target of the shoreland zoning violation charge since he owns and is currently developing the property, which is located on the eastern shore of Long Lake adjacent to the Four Seasons Camping Area.
Chase, who did not return phone calls from the Lakes Region Weekly, is drawing the ire of Naples residents as well as the town’s selectmen, who met Monday night to unanimously order the town attorney to seek the maximum fines against Chase. Those fines could amount to $5,000 a day for the three shoreland zoning ordinance violations, all of which are related to clearing land within 250 feet of shore. According to Town Manager Derik Goodine, the fines could add up to more than $585,000.
The removal of trees by the water’s edge is a concern for water quality since shoreline vegetation acts as a buffer for run-off. Because of the potential environmental concerns, the board’s strongly worded message was applauded by the nearly 100 residents who filled the town hall chambers at Monday night’s standing-room-only meeting.
Town Attorney Geoffrey Hole said Wednesday he will soon meet with Chase’s legal team at Preti Flaherty to see if the matter can be resolved out of court.
“I will be contacting the attorney to see if they are willing to negotiate within the parameters set forth by the selectmen Monday night. If we can’t come to agreement, we’ll file suit,” Hole said.
Chase’s lawyer, Carlie Tuggey, commented after Monday night’s meeting, saying Chase has already acted to fix the violation.
“A restoration plan was agreed upon by the Department of Environmental Protection and the town of Naples code enforcement officer, and we’ve complied with the restoration plan, and that’s where the matter stands,” Tuggey said.
When asked about the restoration plan, Goodine said the town’s code enforcement officer, Boni Rickett, proposed and signed off on a reforestation plan for the Chase land, but that it was based on faulty data given by the state Department of Environmental Protection.
At the meeting on Monday night, Peter Lowell, executive director of the Lakes Environmental Association based in Bridgton, addressed the faulty restoration plan by saying it didn’t comply with state law. He said the several-feet-tall, inch-thick trees that Chase had planted in accordance with Rickett’s request failed to meet state guidelines.
According to the state’s shoreland zoning law, “each tree cut (must be replaced) with a tree of substantially similar size and species to the extent available and feasible.” Since the average diameter of the removed trees was about 12 inches, evidenced by the stumps that were left behind, Lowell said the newly planted “shoots” were “nowhere near compliance.”
Sending a message
In addition to their call for stiff fines, the Naples Board of Selectmen, which has the authority to impose a fine and approve a restoration plan for the site, came out strongly against Chase’s land clearing.
“For me, it was an easy decision,” Selectwoman Christine Powers said after the meeting. “Regarding all the laws, all the ordinances, this violation was wrong. I think the violation was intentional. I think this person knew exactly what they were doing.”
Chairman Bob Caron echoed her ire concerning the issue. “I have no problem going after this individual, I think they should be fined to the limit of the letter of the law,” Caron said.
According to Lowell, there are several reasons why the board is talking so strongly with regard to the land clearing. While the removal of trees and undergrowth could hurt water quality, he said, the board also needed to take swift and strong action to send the message that clearing land down to the water line is unacceptable.
“This is a very serious situation, which is probably the worst I’ve seen in 38 years of work (at LEA). The real danger here is the water quality threat. The value of these lakeside buffers is the last line of defense for water quality,” Lowell said. “But the other danger here is that someone is going to look at this and say, ‘OK, why can’t I do the same thing?'”
Ann McMann, a Naples woman who lives within sight of Chase’s property, likewise urged the selectmen to take strong action on the clear cutting. During the meeting, McMann detailed her thought process after seeing the cleared land for the first time.
“My first thought was, ‘Wow, I didn’t think you could do that.’ And then I thought to myself, ‘Well, those people must have some pull in town.’ And then my further thought was, ‘Well, if they can do that, then I guess there are no holds barred and anyone can do anything,” she said. “That was my progression of thought, and I’m going to imagine that will be many other people’s progression of thoughts once they see that, especially as the summer boating traffic increases.”
Barbara Adlard, who spoke at the meeting and said her grandson predicted the board would slap on a hefty penalty and then walk away, urged for complete revegetation of the cleared property in addition to a stiff penalty, something Selectman Rick Paraschak promised her would happen.
“Once we get the (regrowth) plan, once we get the fines, we’ll hopefully have something in place to monitor for years to come that growth along that shoreline, and that that be part of this settlement that we’re working towards,” he said.
Comments are no longer available on this story