4 min read

As the first heavy snowfall of the season fell on Southern Maine Friday, local superintendents respondended differently, with one canceling school and two choosing to hold classes.

The decision to hold classes in Scarborough upset some parents who thought canceling would have been safer considering the conditions, while the superintendent in Cape Elizabeth said he didn’t hear any coplaints about his decision to cancel.

Superintendents said deciding whether to cancel school is a difficult decision that can prove unpopular because it affects every parent in town.

“It’s rarely an easy call,” said South Portland Superintendent Wendy Houlihan. “So you know the day will be spent with phone calls one way or the other.”

On Friday when some 12 inches of snow fell on the area, the superintendents from Scarborough, Cape Elizabeth and South Portland all arrived at different decisions. Cape Elizabeth canceled school, Scarborough released the students early, and South Portland had school throughout the day, although the high school dismissed about 30 minutes earlier than normal.

Scarborough’s decision was met with a mixed response from parents, many of whom lined up outside of the Middle School at about 11:30 a.m. waiting for school to be dismissed.

Advertisement

Middle School educational technician Dawn Durocher said she would have preferred not to come to school and was particularly concerned about the safety of the roads when her high-school-aged daughter was driving.

“I would have preferred her not to be driving at all,” she said.

However, Paul Brimigion said the schools do the best they can with the information available and sometimes they are right and other times wrong.

“It’s kind of hit or miss,” he said. “What else are you going to do?”

Robin Provencher said she felt the district should have canceled school. She felt so strongly about it that after dropping her child off at the bus stop she e-mailed her child’s teacher saying she would pick him up early because of the bad weather conditions.

“I’m glad I did pick him up early,” she said, adding that until that time she always felt the district made the right decision.

Advertisement

Scarborough Superintendent Bill Michaud said sending the students to school on Friday was a mistake and had he known the size of the storm in the early morning he would have cancelled.

But as the day progressed it was clear that the storm was only going to escalate and he decided to dismiss students early. Michaud said he did receive a lot of calls about the decision.

Cape Superintendent Alan Hawkins said he decided to cancel school on Friday because he felt the storm would not pass and he turned out to be right.

Hawkins said he takes the responsibility for canceling school seriously, and it is important to ensure that students and school staff are safe.

“I feel strongly, from my perspective, it was a good call,” he said, adding that he did not receive one complaint from parents. “You want to get in as many days as possible, but you don’t want to take the chance of something happening.”

Houlihan said she went ahead with school thinking the storm would not have been so bad, and there was no indication of the snow early in the morning.

Advertisement

“We’d love to have a crystal ball,” Houlihan said.

The decision on whether to cancel school is not made out of thin air. On potential snow days each superintendent wakes up at 4 or 5 a.m. and begins calling various people to learn about the storm and the condition of the roads. They must arrive at a decision by 6 a.m.

Some of the people they call include public works crews, police, other superintendents, the district’s transportation office, and the National Weather Service in Gray. Some use the Internet for local weather reports and, in the case of South Portland, a meteorologist who the district contracts also provides some information.

Superintendents also must weigh circumstances specific to each school district. For example, last year South Portland had a number of snow days that Scarborough and Cape Elizabeth did not because the sidewalks were not cleared, which is a problem in South Portland because many students walk to school.

“Each school district has its own conditions that make it a little bit different,” Houlihan said.

The fact that the superintendents are basing their decisions primarily on predictions that do not always ring true makes the job even more difficult.

“It’s probably our most difficult decision because the fact of the matter is you can never be sure,” Michaud said.

Busses lined-up outside of Scarborough Middle School on Friday. The school dismissed students early because of the snowstorm.

Comments are no longer available on this story