When people really want to know what something will cost them, they might say, “Do the math.”
So, let’s do the math concerning the referendum questions before Scarborough voters for $55 million in school buildings. As a follow-up to the guest column that was published a couple of weeks ago, numerous citizens have asked that I provide a more detailed analysis of these projects.
The brochures being distributed around town really don’t give folks an accurate picture of the true construction costs of these projects. The true cost of construction is calculated by adding the annual principal and interest for all bonds associated with the project, then dividing this number by the estimated town assessed valuation. This gives the tax rate increase just from these projects, which is then multiplied by the average residential assessment of $371,600 to obtain the true cost impact of the construction.
Doing the math for all 33 years of debt payments yields the following numbers:
As the cost of the bonds kicks in over a five-year period, the peak year tax impact will be $495 (in 2012) for the average residence, in addition to any other tax increases they may incur between now and then. The average annual cost between 2012 and 2016 will be $462 a year above and beyond any other tax increases. The total out-of-pocket cost over the term of the bonds for the average residence is estimated to be $8,189. These numbers are only based on the costs of construction and equipment and do not include any budget increase for the operating costs.
Now let’s look at the impact in operating costs. The increase in operating costs will also have a direct tax impact resulting from these projects. With that in mind, I made a request on Jan. 9 to the school administration to provide their estimated increase in operating budget expenses. From that time until present, there has been no disclosure in response to my request, nor has there been any public disclosure concerning the estimated increase in operating expenses relating to these projects. We do know that there will be added cost from the estimated 68 new school department employees salaries, benefits and associated additional costs.
Let’s look at enrollment projections furnished by the school department for the 2006 Comprehensive Plan Update. Peak enrollment for the middle school was stated to be 850 students in 2011. The building is proposed for 950 students, but yet the brochures distributed by the school department list 1,100 students as maximum capacity (250 students above their own enrollment projections).
The same pattern continues for the intermediate school. Enrollment projections indicate peak enrollment to be 794 students in 2008. The building is proposed for 900 students. The brochures list 1,058 students as maximum capacity (264 students above their own enrollment projections). Why are the enrollment figures significantly inflated just before the voting? Are these projects realistic to the needs of the community? You be the judge.
The square footage numbers used in my previous guest column were taken from a report filed with the State Board of Education by the director of School Facilities. I have compiled additional data from a report published by the Maine Department of Education that details the costs, square footage and enrollment of every elementary school built in Maine in the last decade. Let’s look at the seven schools built in Maine since 2001 that house 400-plus students.
The total cost of these schools is $92.8 million, with a projected enrollment of 3,550 students. This yields an average cost of $25,400 per student. The intermediate school question on the ballot is for $38.4 million, with projected enrollment of 900 students. This yields a cost per student of $42,700, 67 percent higher than the average of the seven schools built in Maine during this period. A further consideration is that 88 percent of the costs of these seven other schools was funded with state money, leaving only 12 percent to be funded by their local communities. We are being asked to fund 100 percent of a much greater cost. Are we asking our citizens for too much? What do you think?
The chairman of the board of education has publicly acknowledged the schools could probably be built for $5 million less. This raises two questions. Why wasn’t it on the ballot for $5 million less? Could there be a better solution at a greater savings that would also reduce the ongoing operating costs?
Here is just one thought and I’m sure there may be other alternatives. I suggest removing sixth grade from the middle school, which eliminates the need for the $16.6 million addition at that facility. Build a school for Grades 3-6, assuming an average of 300 students per grade, which allows for reasonable growth beyond current estimates. Then apply the state formula for square footage per student. This would result in a building of 150,000 square feet, a 23 percent reduction in size from the $38.4 million building currently proposed. Not only would we be saving on the building, but also we would save on the increases in operating costs as well.
I hope this information has been of value to you as you go the polls to cast your ballot.
Jeffrey Messer
Scarborough Town Council
Comments are no longer available on this story