A half-million dollar payout in damages to a Cape Elizabeth developer has not ended South Portland’s legal woes over its efforts to discontinue Edgewood Road.
Now, the owners of two Cape Elizabeth homes on Edgewood are seeking damages from the city for denying them road access.
Chris and Jayne Boulos, at 60 Edgewood Road, and Debra Sampson and Daniel Maguire, at 59 Edgewood Road, have asked a Cumberland County Superior Court judge to stop South Portland from building a berm across Edgewood to block through traffic.
The July 13 court filing is the latest skirmish in a South Portland-Cape Elizabeth border dispute that has gone on for nearly a decade and poses major legal costs for South Portland.
At issue is South Portland’s attempt to limit traffic along the narrow, tree-lined Edgewood Road in South Portland. The street used to end at the Cape Elizabeth line, but was extended when the Blueberry Ridge subdivision was built by developer Joseph Frustaci.
The city paid Frustaci $523,000 in damages last year, after Maine’s highest court agreed that South Portland hurt his property value by discontinuing the end of Edgewood Road and nearby Charlotte Street.
Great American Insurance Co. covered half the damages. But the city took money from its surplus fund to pay the difference, after the Maine Municipal Association, the city’s other insurer, refused to pay it.
City Attorney Mary Kahl said the Maine Municipal Association is claiming it’s not included in the city’s policy. The city has sued the association over the money.
A spokeswoman for the Maine Municipal Association declined to comment.
Using surplus funds to cover a lawsuit comes at a time when South Portland is being advised by bond houses to increase its reserves to maintain its AA bond rating.
Mayor Claude Morgan said this week the surplus fund exists for emergency spending, such as the legal judgment against South Portland.
“The reality is surplus funds are for exactly these situations,” Morgan said. “Unfortunately, we live in a litigious society. People sue each other and are particularly interested in suing when deep pockets are involved.”
Frustaci claims South Portland’s “refusal to be reasonable” has created bad blood between residents of the two communities.
He said South Portland should be trying harder to calm traffic on Edgewood, rather than blocking the road where it crosses into Cape Elizabeth.
In the most recent court complaint, Bruce McGlauflin – one of the attorneys who represented Frustaci – seeks an injunction to stop South Portland from building a barrier across Edgewood Road.
McGlauflin’s clients – the Bouloses, Maguire and Sampson – object to a berm the city is preparing to build on Edgewood Road at the border of the two communities.
The Cape Elizabeth homeowners were granted private easements by South Portland in 2000 to use Edgewood Road in South Portland. They had no other access to their homes, after the city council voted to discontinue the final 25 feet of Edgewood.
Since then, Frustaci has built another access road to his development, and the council moved to revoke the homeowners’ easements and permanently dead-end the road. The two couples objected.
Complicating the case is the city’s apparent failure to create private easement deeds when they were granted in December 2000. The oversight was discovered by McGlauflin as he prepared his case.
Kahl argues the city does not need to recognize the easements, because they technically do not exist.
“Those deeds were never issued. They fell through the cracks somewhere in the process,” Kahl said. She also said the city has no obligation to compensate the homeowners.
“The logic of that fails me,” McGlauflin argued. “The city promised and put on public record – and even recorded in the registry of deeds – its own decision to grant easement deeds. Apparently even the city itself believed that it had implanted that decision for the last seven years. My clients have operated under those same beliefs. Now the city doesn’t get to benefit from its own inadvertent oversight.”
McGlauflin said his clients are awaiting the judge’s ruling before deciding “whether and how” to pursue damages against the city.
“If we get complete relief from the court, then there is not much basis” for seeking damages, McGlauflin said. “We haven’t alleged any particular dollar amount.”
Morgan said the city also will look carefully at the judge’s ruling on whether to allow the barrier to be built.
“If the judge grants the restraining order against the city, it should be an indicator to us we are on sketchy ground,” Morgan said. “But if he sees a good legal argument here, then we will see how we can prevail.”
Comments are no longer available on this story