Scarborough town councilors remain skeptical about the lynchpin of a town-center development proposed at Scarborough Downs – slot machines.
“They’re asking the town and the Town Council to gamble on gambling,” Councilor Judith Roy said after an Aug. 7 meeting, when developer Gene Beaudoin presented his proposals to the Town Council. “I think it’s a very speculative presentation. There’s no guarantees for the town. Their primary purpose is the racino. All the other things are pies in the sky, the concept of Main Street – we’ve already got Route 1. We don’t need Scarborough Downs’ Main Street..”
Beaudoin’s conceptual drawings show a planned “downtown” with a Main Street linking Route 1 and Payne Road, with downtown-style storefronts, pedestrian-friendly sidewalks, a police building, community center, offices and senior housing.
Scarborough’s comprehensive plan envisions a “town center” at Scarborough Downs – a place more pedestrian-friendly and well-defined than high-speed, multi-lane Route 1 – but residents have refused to allow a casino at the track in the past.
Beaudoin and track officials say the project is not viable without the racino, in part because the infrastructure alone, such as sewer and power lines, would cost about $20 million.
“The owners of the Downs don’t want to do anything prior to the racino,” said Harvey Rosenfeld, Scarborough economic development director.
He said that while slots in Bangor appear to have been relatively successful and positive for the city, Scarborough isn’t Bangor – in part because it already has an established and successful commercial base.
“Bangor is very different from Scarborough,” said Rosenfeld. “It’s downtown. It’s an urban center for Maine. Scarborough is not an urban center. It is really suburban. Also, Scarborough is a very healthy community. Bangor is not as healthy as Scarborough.”
Councilor Ron Ahlquist said he’s not opposed to a casino, but is happy to leave the decision up to voters.
“I’m not strongly opposed or for it. Certainly, it would make a difference in how we do or pay for things,” he said. “I’ve been very impressed with how Bangor is run. From everything everyone said about gambling up in Bangor, ‘The sky is falling’ – it never came about.”
Ahlquist said he has spoken with Bangor officials and law enforcement officers and has not heard any complaints about crime or violence increasing.
Council Chairman Jeffrey Messer said Beaudoin’s ideas “certainly have some merit,” but added that “these benefits must be cautiously weighed against the negative impacts of a racino to see if the project would be in the best interests of the community.
“…The total development of the Downs property, in particular with the integrated downtown, is appealing. A potential revenue source in the area of around $300 million over a 30-year period would give the town a lot of flexibility in meeting substantial infrastructure needs … I’m not a proponent or opponent of the proposal at this stage.”
He noted that any racino would have to pass a townwide vote, “which leaves the decision totally in the hands of the citizens of Scarborough, as it should be.”
Beaudoin said Scarborough residents should be receiving plans for the proposed Main Street/racino development in the mail this week.
Beaudoin is the developer of the recently finished Cabela’s project and soon-to-be-constructed Fairchild Semiconductor corporate headquarters.
Comments are no longer available on this story