4 min read

Tim Gato’s rapid rise from swimming pool supervisor to second in command of South Portland’s largest consolidated department came under fire Monday night during a tense South Portland City Council meeting that focused in part on hiring and promotion practices.

Saying that promotions should be based on skill, not friendship, Buzz Sanborn joined several residents who criticized local officials for recent personnel decisions at City Hall, including Gato’s promotion as the only candidate considered for the post.

“How is it we came upon one person in Parks and Recreation to become the deputy director with no competition for the job?” Sanborn asked. “There had to have been many qualified people who could apply for the job. It needs to be based on merit.”

“Some council members think I am out to ‘get’ the new deputy director,” said resident Nancy Richardson, a frequent critic of recent city layoffs and promotions. “I am pointing out hiring and promotional inequities.”

The council meeting ended with a foiled attempt by Councilor Jim Soule to go into executive session and evaluate City Manager Jim Gailey’s handling of personnel issues.

“It is wrong to put this kind of pressure on our manager and the administration,” said Councilor Linda Boudreau.

Advertisement

Soule’s attempts to review Gailey – both in public and private session – were blocked by Boudreau, with strong support from Jim Hughes and Maxine Beecher. Executive session requires support from five of the seven councilors.

Mayor Tom Blake and Councilors Tom Coward and Patti Smith supported Soule’s motion for the executive session but the simple majority was not enough votes.

At issue is the ongoing controversy over the Feb. 24 layoffs of five veteran city workers: two operations managers, in Public Works and Recreation; two library workers and a benefits clerk.

At least one former worker, Deb Smith, who headed the Recreation Department, has suggested that conflicts she had with Dana Anderson, a top city official, preceded her layoff after 27 years with the city.

Anderson heads Public Works, Parks, Recreation and the Libraries.

Smith has indicated she complained about the management of the Community Center following the promotion of Gato in December 2008.

Advertisement

The city is conducting an independent review of Smith’s written complaints, which she forwarded to Gailey and Blake after her layoff.

Several residents have questioned the layoffs and the reasons behind them. They also have complained about a consolidation in December 2008 of departments that led to Anderson assuming control of the libraries and Gato’s promotion to a newly created position: deputy chief to Anderson.

Gailey has said that Anderson originally suggested combining departments after learning of the idea while attending a regional conference.

At a recent council budget meeting, Anderson referred to Gato as his “heir apparent,” prompting some residents to complain that the hiring was not fairly done.

Meanwhile, city documents show that Anderson endorsed Gato as deputy chief and wrote a job description for the post.

“For the past year, I have treated Tim as an intern/apprentice to my job as director,” Anderson wrote in a memo to Human Resources Director John McGough.

Advertisement

“He has a strong foundation of knowledge and understanding of his current and future challenges our department faces …

“Due to the uncertain times we face and the need to get the ‘right people at the table’ … I feel this is the right thing to do and the right time to do it,” Anderson wrote in the 2008 memo.

Gato has worked for the city since 2002, when he was hired as pool coordinator, earning $716 a week. He took over additional responsibilities, becoming pool supervisor and overseeing the transfer station. The extra work came with raises.

In 2008, he received three separate raises – bringing his pay from $965.60 per week in January 2008 to $1,163.60 in December 2008.

Monday night, two people spoke out to defend Anderson, who has been put on paid leave since he settled a civil court case involving embezzlement allegations unrelated to his job with the city.

The International Association of Affiliated Basketball Officials charged that Anderson embezzled $37,000 when he volunteered as treasurer for the organization.

Advertisement

Anderson denied the charges but was put on administrative leave pending a financial audit of his department.

Michelle Fickett, a secretary at the Community Center, said she felt personally attacked by the recent criticisms of Anderson. She said the complaints of residents do not represent her views.

Anderson’s longtime secretary – who is his sister-in-law – also spoke in favor of her boss. She credited Anderson with maintenance of city parks and the development of the Community Center, which voters approved for development.

Deb Smith was put in charge of the Community Center by Anderson when it opened in 2000.

“People are here to (find out) what are the roles and responsibilities” of city officials, said former City Councilor Rosemarie de Angelis. “Is everyone upholding their duties and doing their job? The public has a right to come down here and speak and say whatever it is they want to say.”

Comments are no longer available on this story