The Maine ethics commission last week levied a $12,250 fine against backers of a casino referendum in Scarborough for filing late financial reports.
The ethics commission also questioned the late disclosure of $30,000 paid to a local lawyer for consulting services in the campaign.
The Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election practices ruled that the Scarborough Village Partnership political action committee violated ethics laws for registering and filing its campaign reports late with the Scarborough town clerk.
According to the commission’s finding, the PAC registered on Sept. 26 and filed its first campaign report on Oct. 24. Commission Chairman Jonathan Wayne said the PAC should have registered on Aug. 26 and filed its campaign financing reports by Oct. 10.
Downs officials had proposed adding slots to the track as part of a $200 million commercial and residential development that would have given the town a center and $8 million in annual revenues.
Pitched by Connecticut developer Gene Beaudoin, the proposal to develop 535 acres owned by the track lost by just 239 votes. It was backed by Penn National Gaming Inc., which spent $135,000 on the PAC’s campaign in support of the project, according to campaign finance reports.
According to the ethics commission’s report, Scarborough Town Clerk Tody Justice told the PAC’s treasurer, Kathryn Rolston, that Scarborough Village Partnership had until Sept. 26 to register as a PAC and had until Oct. 24 to file its campaign finance reports.
Maine law requires finance reports from PACs that spend more than $1,500 in a referendum campaign in towns of at least 15,000 people.
“I think (the fine) was an unfortunate decision,” Rolston said on Monday. “I was penalized for my late registration, and I was following the advice given to me by Scarborough officials and ethics officials. I think the board came down really hard on me.”
The Scarborough Village Partnership can appeal its fine to Superior Court.
Wayne said the late filings could have stemmed from a change last year in the filing deadline that Scarborough officials were not aware of.
Scarborough Downs attorney Ed MacColl said he learned at the March 26 hearing that Justice had received e-mails from an ethics commissioner after Oct. 24 informing her of the law change.
“It’s spelled out in the statute that that’s a reason to waive the fine, MacColl said.
Justice was away from the municipal offices until Tuesday after the Current’s deadline, and was not available for comment. She had previously declined to comment for a story regarding the fines.
Dennis Bailey, spokesman for Casinos No!, said he was happy with the commission’s fine against Penn National. A Scarborough citizens group, Save our Scarborough, enlisted the help of Casinos No! last year to battle the racino proposal.
Bailey added that he thinks the late filing was more than just a misinformed mistake.
“It was all part of their campaign and at least one commissioner agreed it was pretty convenient,” Bailey said on Friday. “My point that I made with the commission is (Penn) may have gotten wrong information, but the fact that the voters didn’t hear the truth or hear the fact that Penn was behind this is totally consistent with Penn constantly downplaying the role of casinos, slots, and in some cases to even deny that Penn National was even involved.”
MacColl said Bailey is inaccurate with that statement and that Penn National never hid its involvement.
“That was never unknown to anyone,” MacColl said. “That notion is simply false.”
Penn National did not return an e-mail or telephone request for a comment.
The commission also questioned a $30,000 consulting service fee for Scarborough lawyer Dan Warren, Wayne said.
According to Wayne, Warren, a former town councilor and state legislator who is also a columnist for the Current, was featured in a local advertisement supporting the development of a racino at Scarborough Downs.
Filings prior to the election did not show that Warren was paid on Oct. 14 for his services. An amended filing, submitted in January, showed Warren was paid on Oct. 14.
Rolston said she knew Warren had done consulting work for Penn National and the PAC, but didn’t become aware that he was paid until January.
“I was not aware of the details of his contract,” Rolston said. “When I was filling out the PAC report, I realized we didn’t have any information on him. I assumed the report would come through the Scarborough PAC, but it was actually paid for by Penn National. When I tracked it down and realized he had been paid, I filed the report immediately.”
In a written statement, Warren said his law firm, Jones and Warren, did about three months’ work for racino proponents. He became involved in the issue because he supports harness racing and at the request of MacColl, whom he knew from college.
The work “involved both legal analysis, consideration of local and state laws, and political consulting. We also ended up assisting with the ballot inspection brought on by the close margin at the polls,” he wrote.
As to the late filing of reports, he wrote, “I am told a state agency has reviewed whether racino proponents filed certain paperwork in a timely fashion with the government during the referendum season. Filing reports was not part of the
duties our law firm was asked to take on.”
The commission also found that Casinos No! violated disclosure laws by not amending its PAC registration that it was opposing the Scarborough referendum. No fine was levied against that PAC.
“The PAC should have amended its registration form to the state that they were opposed to the Scarborough referendum,” Wayne said. “However, a majority of the commissioners felt that by sending copies to the town clerk of their updated forms was adequate enough, which is why we didn’t levy a fine.”
MacColl said that he was surprised and confused as to why Casinos No! didn’t get a fine.
“It just strikes me as bizarre,” he said. “One way or another, however, I view it as stuff happens. I think Dennis takes some liberties with the facts, but he’s a campaign person and that’s what they do, and the First Amendment protects that process.”
Comments are no longer available on this story