The Taxation Committee has identified more than $200 million in new sales taxes that could be raised to allow a decrease in the income tax to a flat 5 or 6 percent – tax reform that even proponents say will take courage to pass in the Legislature.
The list of currently exempt items that could be tapped under an expansion of the sales tax includes everything from cable TV service to summer camp and dozens of items in between. Some of the more remarkable are funeral services and visits to the barber.
“We’re already talking about taxing funerals. Then you’re going to tax the poor guy in the casket for a haircut. Where are we going to stop?” asked Rep. Herb Clark, D-Millinocket, a member of the committee.
As it has done in years past, the list of possible exemptions that could be eliminated and therefore subject more goods and services to a 5 percent sales tax have left business lobbyists agape, even though most support a decrease in the income tax as a way to encourage new businesses to settle and grow in Maine.
Maine has one of the highest top individual income tax rates in the country that kicks in at a relatively low income. It is argued that rate hurts small businesses, which run their taxes through the individual tax line, and also discourages larger companies from locating here because high income tax rates hurt their employees.
The increased sales taxes also would pay for property tax breaks for all Maine-based homeowners through an increase in the Homestead Exemption.
But the tradeoff is painful.
On the new tax list are sales taxes on funeral services, cosmetic surgery, haircuts, health club memberships, cleaning, household repair, newspapers and magazines, movie, theater and sports tickets and for-profit summer camps, to name a few.
Also being discussed is an increase in the meals and lodging tax – currently at 7 percent – to anywhere from 8 to 10 percent; a hike in the tax on beer and wine; a new tax on soda pop; and, a return of the snack tax, which is essentially the 5 percent sales tax on snack grocery items. One proposal also recommends raising the tax rate from 5 to 6 percent on top of expanding the base.
The money raised would fund one of a series of proposals that lower the income tax rate. Several keep the graduated tax system, but lower the top income tax rate – currently at 8.5 percent – and the subsequent rates beneath it. Others create a flat income tax of 5 or 6 percent, with deeper tax breaks for lower- and middle-income residents created through tax credits to keep the income tax progressive.
“It’s going to take a lot of courage to do something like this,” said Rep. Thom Watson, D-Bath, who is sponsoring one of the more modest proposals by comparison. “I’m talking about marketability inside (the statehouse).”
While some lobbyists predict the Tax Committee’s reform package will never see the light of day, House Speaker Glenn Cummings said he is open to something that lowers the income tax.
“I think the No. 1 criteria is for working class families and Maine small businesses to have their income taxes lowered,” said Cummings. “If we’re confident they will be better off at the end of the day because of this tax reform,” he said, the Democrats in the House could support it.
The key is the tax reform package has to be revenue neutral or, better yet, reduces overall tax burden by “exporting” burden via the sales tax, Cummings said. That means more of the state’s taxes will be paid by tourists, out-of-state corporations or part-time residents.
The Maine Revenue Service is estimating the plans currently under review by the Taxation Committee export anywhere from $118 to $180 million in taxes.
The committee will continue its work through the rest of the week, with the hope now of having a proposal to recommend by Friday. That was its hope last week, but the process has taken longer than expected.
Still on the agenda for discussion is a companion to the tax shifting that calls for tighter controls on spending and raising taxes in the future.
A bipartisan plan proposed by Sen. Richard Nass, R-York County, and Sen. Ethan Strimling, D-Cumberland County, calls for a constitutional amendment requiring a two-thirds vote of the Legislature to increase the income, excise or sales tax rate and a two-thirds vote of a local elected body or town meeting to increase the mil rate.
Comments are no longer available on this story