6 min read

A Standish lawmaker this week submitted a bill that would bring a second racino to Maine, this time in the southern portion of the state.

Rep. Gary Moore, R-Standish, wants to give southern Maine towns the chance to build a harness racing track featuring up to 1,500 slot machines. Moore’s goal with the bill is to have the racino help pay the reintroduction of rail travel along the Mountain Division rail line, which extends from Portland through the Lakes Region into Fryeburg.

“The fact of the matter is that the Mountain Division rail probably could not sustain itself. And we don’t want taxpayers having to pay for it,” Moore said. “My thought is that a racino, which has been wildly successful in Bangor, could help make the rail line a reality.”

Moore said proceeds from the racino would help sustain not only the Mountain Division line, but the Amtrak line as well. He said time is ticking on the Downeaster track since the federal government is cutting subsidies to the line in 2008.

“You can’t go wrong here money-wise. You can talk about the morality of it, but money-wise, racinos are a proven moneymaker,” Moore said. “And if we want rail travel here in Maine, we’re going to need some way to pay for it.”

According to Moore’s bill, only one racino could be built in southern Maine, and it would have to be located in one of the towns that abut the Amtrak line or Mountain Division line. According to the bill, towns would need voter approval to build the racino and would need to prove its comprehensive plan accommodates such a use. Once those requirements have been met, Maine’s Gambling Control Board would have to approve the operation. Then, Maine voters would get the final say in a statewide referendum.

Advertisement

Moore’s racino proposal calls for a harness racing track as well as slot machines located no more than 200 feet from the track. Maine law currently allows 3,000 slot machines in the state. Bangor Raceway already has 1,500 machines, allowing another 1,500 to be set up.

In total, whichever entity runs the track will get 61 percent of the profits from both harness racing and slot machines. Thirty-nine percent of the profits will go toward a combination of programs. Of that, 10 percent will go toward paying for the Mountain Division Rail Line and 2 percent would help sustain the Amtrak Downeaster line.

While he hails from Standish, Moore eyes the Route I-95 corridor as the most likely spot for a southern Maine racino.

“It doesn’t matter where the racino goes. That’s up to residents in the town. But I could easily see it going in towns such as Old Orchard Beach or Scarborough,” Moore said. “Of course, I’d love to see it in Standish.”

In Standish, Councilor Lou Stack, who has been pushing for the redevelopment of the Mountain Division rail line for years, is excited about commuter rail coming back to town. He hasn’t heard details of Moore’s racino plan, but is open-minded. He said he will listen to Moore present his plan to the Route 113 Corridor Commission before making up his mind on the proposal. But he said he is excited about any proposal that revives the rail.

“I can hardly believe it. Everything we can do to promote it brings us one step closer” to having rail back in Standish, he said.

Advertisement

Scarborough Town Manager Ronald Owens said Moore’s proposal sounds similar to a proposal Scarborough residents defeated several years ago. In 2003, slot machines were to be added to Scarborough Downs to help prop up the harness racing industry in Maine.

“It’s funny how these lawmakers are trying to legitimize casino gambling by attaching a good cause for the money that’s generated. Last time was to help revive harness racing and raise money for seniors’ prescription drugs and state fairs. This time racinos will help save the railroads. That’s very interesting,” Owens said.

Old Orchard Beach Town Manager Jim Thomas echoes Owens’ concerns about a southern Maine racino.

“On the surface, I don’t see Old Orchard Beach being a player in that,” Thomas said. “During the last go ’round with this topic, the majority of residents here were not in favor of the racino idea. And I don’t see the winds of change shifting anytime soon.”

Thomas added that the idea of a racino is morally questionable “because it takes money from people who really can’t afford it,” a concern echoed by Casinos No! and Gov. John Baldacci.

David Farmer, spokeman for Gov. Baldacci’s office, said the governor has repeatedly opposed the expansion of gambling in Maine because of the economic downsides of the activity.

Advertisement

“It’s not this silver bullet. There’s no free lunch. The money that is made at these venues comes straight out of the pocket of the people of Maine,” Farmer said. “The governor believes the gambling industry is built on false promises and that there are better ways to encourage economic development.”

Dennis Bailey, executive director of Casinos No!, said Moore’s bill is one of 18 or 19 others that calls for racinos or casinos to help pay for various infrastructure improvements or cultural projects in Maine.

“Everyone wants to get into the act – social groups, tribes. Where’s it going to stop? Fact is, I don’t think Maine people want their state to become like Las Vegas,” Bailey said.

But Moore argues that the racino in Bangor, which the southern Maine racino would emulate, has been a stellar operation with none of the moral downside naysayers predicted.

“You go to Bangor. You won’t see prostitutes or people down and out because they’ve lost everything to their gambling addiction. That sort of thing just hasn’t happened,” Moore said. “I’ve talked to people from all walks of life about my proposal. They’re very enthusiastic about it.”

Cosponsor of Moore’s bill, Sen. Lois Snowe-Mello, R-Androscoggin, said she believes the positives of the proposal outweigh the negatives.

Advertisement

“I really am a strong opponent of any kind of gambling, but I know there are consituents in my district who want racinos and I’m trying to be fair,” she said. “I can support it, however, knowing that the bill calls for strong local control. The people in the town have to approve.”

While he opposes Moore’s plan, Sen. Bill Diamond, D-Cumberland County, said he “applauds” Moore for “thinking outside the box.”

“It’s going to take some money to revive the rail, but I’m not convinced the racino’s the way we need to go,” Diamond said.

Diamond is hopeful that a private company will take over the operation of the rail after the state pays to re-establish the track.

Moore’s bill would also require the establishment of a rail authority to oversee the racino’s operation as well as overseeing improvement or maintenance projects for the rail lines. The Mountain Division Rail Line Authority would have bonding power, Moore said, allowing it to finance improvement projects without voter approval.

The authority would consist of the Maine Commissioner of Transportation and four members appointed by the governor.

There is question whether Moore’s bill has the support to get through the Legislative Council. The council is a bipartisan group made up of Democrat and Republican leaders that decides whether or not late bills get heard. Bailey said there is little chance that Moore’s bill will “have legs” since it’s late in the session and there are other racino proposals that could bump Moore’s bill off the legislative docket.

“Another wrinkle is the Washington County racino proposal, which has 50,000-plus signatures and is headed to referendum in November,” Bailey said. “All similar bills are essentially moot when a citizen-intiated bill is set to be on the ballot. So, with that in mind, I don’t even see this getting through.”

Comments are no longer available on this story