RAYMOND – Bucking a growing trend among towns located along the Portland-to-Montreal oil pipeline, the Raymond Board of Selectmen Tuesday night rejected a resolution pertaining to any future project for pumping so-called tar sands oil through the pipeline.
The board was revisiting the issue since tabling a decision at its February meeting. Tuesday’s discussion was preceded by public comment from oil industry executives, environmental group officials and area residents. Nearly all public comment was urging the board to adopt the resolution, which would have requested a full environmental review by state and federal regulators should the Portland Montreal Pipeline Co. reverse the direction of its 60-year-old pipeline in order to ship tar sands.
Joe Bruno, Lonnie Taylor and Mike Reynolds voted against the resolution, with Chairman Sam Gifford and Charley Leavitt supporting the measure.
The pipeline was installed during World War II and transports crude from tank farms in South Portland to refineries in Montreal. There is a pumping station for the underground line on Route 121 in Raymond, and the line runs by Panther Run, Sebago Lake and other environmentally sensitive areas of the town and surrounding Lakes Region.
Environmental groups such as Environment Maine and the Natural Resources Council of Maine have lobbied local governments along the pipeline to adopt resolutions that call on the federal government to block the transport of Canadian oil sands through water-rich Maine. In Vermont, where the pipeline also runs on its way to Montreal, more than a dozen towns adopted anti-tar sands resolutions this week during their annual town meetings. Three towns in Maine –
Waterford, Bethel and Casco –
have already adopted resolutions opposing tar-sands transport.
David Cyr, chief financial officer for the pipeline company, said at the meeting there is no project in the works. The company’s chief executive officer, Larry Wilson, has said he would be open to shipping tar sands if a project was offered.
At its meeting last month, Raymond selectmen decided to table a more strongly worded resolution that was drafted by Environment Maine. The revised version presented this week was drafted by Selectman Mike Reynolds, who requested that Raymond write its own resolution rather than signing off on language drafted by a special interest organization. The revised wording, which was described at the meeting as a watered-down version of the original, was approved by Gifford.
While Gifford and Leavitt voted to adopt the revised resolution, arguing that it merely called for an environmental review of the aging pipe and the impact an oil sands spill could have on the town’s water bodies, Reynolds, who was considered a swing vote, voted against the resolution he helped to draft.
Reynolds said he wasn’t sure if the resolution was necessary if the state and federal government was already slated to do an automatic review of a reversal project if it is proposed. He and Selectman Bruno said they weren’t sure of the review process.
Reynolds also took issue with those such as Environment Maine’s Emily Figdor, who said during public comment that Maine has nothing to gain and much to lose by allowing oil sands transport. Reynolds said their argument is a “not-in-my-backyard” approach, “and I have a hard time with Not-In-My-Backyard.” Reynolds also complained about a deluge of form emails from Environment Maine, which he described as spam.
Reynolds also cited a 2,000-page report released recently by the U.S government on the chemical composition of Canadian tar sands, an in-depth study that Joe Bruno referred to as well during the discussion. Bruno said the report found that oil sands from Canada is compositionally similar to crude oil and doesn’t create any more corrosion. Bruno said environmental groups have misled Mainers into believing tar-sands is thicker and more corrosive, similar to liquid sandpaper, as Figdor has described its consistency, and “that’s not true,” Bruno said citing the government report.
The report is lengthy, and Reynolds said he would like to read more of it before voting on any local resolution. He also said he doesn’t want to rush an important decision.
“It’s a lot to digest, and I don’t want to make a decision too quickly, but at the same time I want to protect our environment,” Reynolds said after the meeting. “There is nothing pressing here. There is no proposal that’s going to go before Congress or the president, so I don’t feel like I have to make a decision this month when another month of answering my questions is going to get me more knowledge and a more comfortable response.”
Bruno also said he opposed the resolution on political grounds, saying environmental groups would take advantage of Raymond’s vote if it were to pass Tuesday night.
“What’s going to happen is they’re going to say Raymond just jumped on this bandwagon with these resolutions so therefore here’s another town that we can notch on our belt,” Bruno said, echoing a public comment earlier in the meeting in which John Quinn, director of the New England Petroleum Council, said the town “is being used” by political forces intent on blocking more oil shipments from Canada.
After the meeting, Figdor said she “was extremely disappointed. There is so much at risk with this project. Tar sands oil is a completely different product. We’ve seen what’s happened in the past when it’s spilled into waterways and we know there are risks, so the idea that the Board of Selectmen would not go forward with a resolution to study those risks, it’s really hard to comprehend.”
Figdor said environmental groups are not trying to make political hay out of the issue, either to fill their own coffers or to forward a larger agenda aimed at reducing oil consumption by targeting smaller and more politically vulnerable pipeline companies rather than the more powerful oil producers.
“We want to ensure a study is done, and right now there is no assurance,” Figdor said. “We’re working to protect the waterways of Raymond and the drinking water that so many people in Maine rely on. And that’s it. We’re not the oil industry in search of profits so I really reject the idea that this is something we’d take and politicize.”
Reynolds said the issue isn’t dead in Raymond. In a phone interview Wednesday, Reynolds said he may have voted no Tuesday night, but “I think we had a good discussion. And I believe a month from now, we may be having a conversation on why I voted yes because I [would then have] my questions answered.”
Comments are no longer available on this story