3 min read

If there’s one thing you notice right away about the Scarborough High School Debate Team members, it’s that they talk fast.

Really fast.

Win-an-argument-before-the-opponent-opens-his-mouth kind of fast.

You start to realize that an encounter with this Scarborough team is probably not pretty for the other side. Take this winter, for example. First, the team traveled to a debate every Saturday, competed against a half-dozen or so other teams, and won every time. Then, for the third year in a row, the team took home the first-place trophy in the statewide Student Congress Debate competition in January, along with several individual awards.

More recently, one member, Jeremy Carter, qualified to compete in a national competition in Las Vegas this spring. Two more, Katie Flynn and Matt Couillard, have qualified to serve as alternates.

What’s their secret?

Advertisement

“I am a really argumentative person,” volunteers junior Amanda Ek. “I love proving people wrong. It’s kind of exhilarating, I guess.”

Or maybe it’s their commitment. In addition to being students, and in many cases athletes, the debate team members give up their entire Saturdays to debate, often staying up late the night before to write speeches.

The speeches – on subjects from illegal immigration to importation of prescription drugs – have to be well-researched and backed up by facts. They have to be complete, compelling and persuasive.

And they have to last no longer than three minutes – hence the debate team’s propensity for speed-talking.

After speaking, debaters have to remain on their toes to answer questions – most of them hostile – from fellow students. Stumbling here, and it’s as bad as flubbing your speech when you stand up to the podium.

“Judges look for facts,” Carter said.

Advertisement

A little political ability doesn’t hurt, either. Just ask Carter, the somewhat conservative Las Vegas hopeful, what he thinks of building a wall along the Mexican border to stem illegal immigration. Does he favor the idea?

“Not a full wall, no,” Carter replies.

Why not?

“Researching it, I realized it wasn’t the best option,” he says authoritatively. “I realized it wasn’t financially viable.”

Carter is one of several debate team members eying a future in politics.

Others say debating has made them more confident, better speakers and more knowledgeable about current events.

Advertisement

And while competing can be “agony,” as junior Christine Rousselle puts it, it’s “really a lot of fun. I get a ridiculous rush from being up there,” she says. “Once you get there, you just get into the zone.”

Team members agree that the most nerve-wracking time is not the actual competition, however. It’s the roughly two hours it takes the judges to decide who won.

“Waiting for awards is really the worst part,” Carter said. “We really didn’t know (at the state meet, who won). We were on the edge of their seats.”

In the end, however, the nerves, the early mornings and the late nights were worth it, as Scarborough took home the state trophy for yet another year.

“We have nothing to complain about,” Carter said.

Debate team members: Grade 12, Nimrod Drizlikh, Will Hamill, Colin Mack. Grade 11, Jeremy Carter, Matt Couillard, Amanda Ek, Katie Flynn, Kseniya Levina, Christine Rousselle, James Wright. Grade 10, Kevin Cai, Joe Prosack, Roscoe Thomas. Grade 9, Seth Albert, Henry Chen, Arthur Hamill, Ben Howard, Orin James. The team is coached by English teacher Gerry Hebert.

Comments are no longer available on this story