SOUTH PORTLAND – The South Portland City Council gave initial approval Monday to extending a moratorium on any development proposal involving the flow of tar-sands oil into the city.
Now, the extension, which would give the city’s Draft Ordinance Committee until Nov. 1 to make its recommendations and proposals regarding the regulation of tar sands, will go to the Planning Board for review before coming back to the council for a final vote on April 23.
Officially, the committee is made up of three members – Michael Conathan and David Critchfield from South Portland and Russell Pierce, Jr. from Portland. However there are also a number of people who are volunteering their time to assist the committee in its work, according to Jeff Edelstein, the facilitator working with the group.
The committee was charged by the City Council with “development of ordinance language to address development proposals involving oil sands/tar sands products,” according to the application for membership on the committee.
The application also states that the city sought individuals, preferably residents of South Portland, with “experience in land use law and/or drafting land use ordinance language.”
According to City Manager Jim Gailey, “The Draft Ordinance Committee is doing yeoman’s work and there is great momentum, but they are running out of time and [this extension] would give them the time they need.”
The moratorium is set to expire on May 5, and while Edelstein said the committee members have been hard at work for the past month, they are simply not going to be able to meet that deadline.
“We have a fair amount of material to work through and this is a complicated issue,” Edelstein said.
City Attorney Bill Dale said there were two standards the city must meet in order for the extension of the moratorium to be legal.
The first is that the problem or issue still exists and, secondly, that the city is “making progress in good faith” toward addressing the problem.
Dale said as long as the Draft Ordinance Committee continued to work diligently, the City Council would be justified in extending the moratorium. And, in this particular case, he said, there is plenty of evidence to support the extension.
Natalie West, a local attorney and member of the group Protect South Portland, which is opposed to allowing any tar sands to flow into the city, thanked the council for passing the initial moratorium and urged them to also pass the extension.
“[The Draft Ordinance Committee] obviously meets the standard of making ‘reasonable progress,’” she said.
Patricia White, another resident who supports the work of the Draft Ordinance Committee, also urged the council to grant the extension.
“The [committee] is doing phenomenal work and it’s very important to extend the moratorium,” she said.
City Councilor Michael Pock was the lone vote against extending the moratorium on the first reading. He argued that there was no need for the moratorium in the first instance, and he would not support “making a good corporate citizen [Portland Pipe Line Corp.] the bad guy.”
Councilor Linda Cohen made the motion to extend the moratorium and said she was “happy to move this forward. No matter what the outcome, the committee is doing good work and collecting good information.”
Councilor Patti Smith agreed.
“I’m glad we have this tool in our toolbox so that we can take as much time as we need to,” she said.
And Mayor Gerard Jalbert said, it was “reasonable” to extend the moratorium until November.
A CLOSER LOOK
South Portland’s Draft Ordinance Committee, which is working on recommendations for regulating tar-sands operations within the city’s limits, is scheduled to give the City Council an update on its progress at 7 p.m. on Monday, March 24, at City Hall. See http://www.southportland.org/departments/city-clerk/draft_ordinance_committee for more information about the committee, including its agendas and meeting schedule.
Comments are no longer available on this story