There are a lot of misconceptions being spread around about the tax reform implemented by Gov. Paul LePage and 125th Legislature. Most of the partisan mudslinging is coming from left-leaning sources who want to diminish one of the great accomplishments of Maine conservatives and the LePage administration.
The tax reform, implemented as part of the biennial budget in 2011, reduced the top income tax rate from 8.5 percent to 7.95 percent – the largest reduction of that rate in Maine history. We’re still a long way from having a competitive tax policy, of course. According to the Tax Foundation, a nonprofit organization that researches and analyzes tax policy in the United States, Maine’s income tax remains the 9th highest of all states that levy such a tax. But the roughly 6.5-percent rate reduction was a step in the right direction and a major advancement of economic freedom.
Left-wingers like to say that the income tax rate reduction was a Republican giveaway to wealthy Mainers, but there’re a few things they don’t want to tell you.
First, they don’t want you to know that the tax reform was enacted with overwhelming bipartisan support. Progressives like Senate President Justin Alfond (D-Portland) and Sen. Emily Cain (D-Orono) both voted in favor of the tax cuts.
Second, they don’t want you to know that Maine’s top income tax rate applies to individuals making more than $20,900 and married couples making $41,850. LePage’s tax cuts were “tax cuts for the rich” only if you consider a single woman making $25,000 a year wealthy. I certainly don’t.
A less appreciated feature of the GOP tax reform was the doubling – from $1 million to $2 million – of the death tax exemption. In practice, this reform allows small business owners, such as family-owned farms, to stay in business when the primary owner dies. Now, a farmer with an estate worth less than $2 million can pass his farm down to his children without the state handing his descendants a gigantic bill that, in some cases, forces a property sale.
Despite the broad range of Mainers benefiting from LePage’s tax relief package – including 70,000 low-income Mainers who will pay no state income tax as a result – liberals have summoned the spirit of Occupy Wall Street to vilify those who would let Mainers keep more of their hard-earned money. To do so, the left is relying on some inaccurate claims.
Most recently, Rep. Mike Michaud (D-ME), who is running for governor, has levied an inaccurate criticism against LePage and other tax reform supporters. On more than three occasions, Michaud has said that reducing the top income tax rate caused instability in government because it was done “outside of the budget cycle.” That’s just not true.
The budget cycle for fiscal years 2012-2013 concluded on July 30, 2013. The reduced rates took effect in the tax year beginning Jan. 1, 2012. As state Rep. Kathleen Chase (R-Wells), a member of the Appropriations and Financial Affairs Committee, has said, “The package implemented tax cuts beginning on Jan. 1, 2012 and ramping up each year thereafter. The tax cuts began taking effect well within the biennial budget cycle of the 125th Maine Legislature.” Charts produced by Maine’s Office of Fiscal and Program Review, the office responsible for helping elected officials write budgets, confirm that the cuts were enacted within the budget cycle.
So why the rhetorical attacks on this smart, responsible tax reform? It could be that the left is not really upset about how or when those tax cuts were enacted. It could be that the left is instead upset by any attempt to limit the size and growth of state government and state spending, as tax cuts tend to do.
One of the most powerful constituencies on the left is the government workers’ union. Here in Maine they go by the name, Maine State Employees Association (MSEA). Unlike private sector unions, the MSEA benefits uniquely from the growth of government.
Indeed, there is a direct relationship between MSEA’s cash flow and the number of government employees. Because Maine is not a Right-to-Work state, government workers are forced to pay dues or fees to the MSEA, even if they’d rather not. More state workers means more money for the MSEA, its lobbyists and bosses. It’s not surprising, then, that the MSEA tends to oppose policies and politicians that won’t add taxpayer-funded employees to the state payroll.
Conservatives can begin to sound like a broken record when it comes to taxes, but that’s because it’s centrally important to public policy. Taxes intersect with our lives in a way that other policies simply don’t. On a personal level, lower taxes means higher take-home pay and better lives for Maine people. And over the long term, a low tax environment will allow Maine a chance to have a truly thriving economy. Instead of “Going Out of Business” tax policies we need a “Getting into Business Sale” on income tax rates, 50 percent off every year until we get to zero income tax; just like the most prosperous states in the Union.
Peter V. Anania is chairman of the Maine Heritage Policy Center, on the board of the Windham Economic Development Corporation and a former Windham town councilor.
Comments are no longer available on this story