3 min read

On June 13 voters will resolve the nearly year-long debate in Cape Elizabeth over the efficacy of “short-cut” streets, or streets connecting previously dead-end neighborhoods.

The “no short-cuts” petition developed by the Neighbors for Sensible Development as protection from a proposed 42 unit subdivision that threatens to connect Killdeer Road and Dermot Drive, creating a throughway between two major arterial roads Mitchell Road and Spurwink Avenue, would alter the future of planning in Cape Elizabeth.

Though 10 percent of registered voters were required to sign the petition to make it valid, if one more voter favors than opposes it, it will become law. If the petition passes, the Spurwink Woods developers will be forced to find a new way in and out of their proposed neighborhood.

Neighbors say the Spurwink Woods development, which prompted the petition, will introduce traffic into their neighborhoods that will compromise their quiet lives, and pose safety risks for their children. Commuting traffic will use the new road as a throughway to major arterials, they say.

Developers and planners say there are engineering tricks to deter potential cut-through traffic. Spurwink Woods developers have worked with the neighbors over the past several months, trying to develop a plan suitable to neighbors to slow traffic. Extra stop signs, raised crosswalks, and a curving design have all been proposed should the petition fail at the polls. However, the neighbors have requested a gate be erected, which a slim majority of the planning board favors.

Planners and public safety officials have raised concerns about safety impediments to dead-end neighborhoods. They say a single entrance and exit to any neighborhood is a safety hazard that sets their alarm bells ringing. They argue that if something were to obstruct the roadway they would need another point of entry.

Advertisement

However, Priscilla Armstrong, who has lived in the dead-end neighborhood Shore Acres for 18 years, said she’s never felt unsafe. She can’t recall a time that road blockages have deterred safety vehicles from entering her neighborhood.

If there were an extraordinary circumstance that could potentially threaten her and her neighbor’s safety, Armstrong feels confident she and her neighbors would pull together to rectify it quickly. “If a tree fell in the road, a lot of people own chainsaws,” she said. “We’d be down there chopping it up.”

Armstrong’s sentiments reinforce the neighbors’ argument that many people chose to live in dead-end neighborhoods, because of the limited traffic disruption. They don’t want their streets connected.

However, resident Greg Jordan adamantly opposes the petition and will vote against it on June 13. The neighbors who created the petition suffer from NIMBY-ism, he said, or “Not In My Back Yard Syndrome.”

Jordan said the neighbors clearly oppose the development, though they have claimed time and again they don’t. “They threw every imaginable objection at the project, from environmental and traffic concerns, to scare tactics such as the potential running over of little children.”

Town Councilor Paul McKenney said he understands the neighbors desire to keep their dead-end neighborhoods, but he thinks the neighbors are missing the bigger picture. “There are negative ramifications for future planning…I’m not sure people really understand what those ramifications are,” he said.

Advertisement

McKenney supports the planning philosophy of interconnected neighborhoods and echoed planners and public safety concerns about limited access in emergency situations.

Interconnected neighborhoods are better planning, said McKenney.

“Every study I’ve read tells me that’s true,” he said.

Zoning Board of Appeals member Mike Tranfaglia is still on the fence and sympathizes with both sides.

Tranfaglia has observed what he calls “tension points” for residents in the town. Connectivity or joining neighborhoods and cluster development, which increases neighborhood density, are some of these tension points. They’re both goals for the town, be he questioned whether they are really what residents want.

He suggested the petition might serve as a catalyst to reevaluate these planning goals in the comprehensive plan, which a committee has been working on updating since June 2005. “This is a great time to investigate instead of having this gold standard,” he said.

The comprehensive plan committee is seeking public input on the plan at a forum scheduled for June 15 at 7 p.m. in Town Hall.

Comments are no longer available on this story