SCARBOROUGH – The Scarborough Town Council is scheduled to get its first look this week at a contract zone proposal that would bring a new $17.5 million Maine Army National Guard readiness center and $15 million field maintenance shop to town.
The council and the Planning Board were set to meet in a joint session on Wednesday, after the Current’s deadline, to hold a preliminary review of the project, which is a co-application from the University of New England and the National Guard.
The project, if approved, would be built on a 38-acre site off Route 1 on the border between Scarborough and Saco. Most of the land, 24.6 acres, is in Scarborough and is now owned by the University of New England, which is based in Biddeford, but which also has a campus on Stevens Avenue in Portland.
The school’s desire to acquire the adjacent Stevens Avenue Armory, and its 9-acre site, from the Maine Army National Guard is the impetus behind the proposal to move the guard to Scarborough.
A contract zone is required for the project because under Scarborough’s zoning ordinances, the readiness center and maintenance shop are not listed as permitted or special exception uses in the rural farm zone.
Under the contract zone proposal, the University of New England would essentially swap the undeveloped land it bought from Cleve Worster for the armory, according to Bill Bola, vice president for operations at the college.
Prior to Wednesday’s council meeting, Bola told the Current that the University of New England has been talking with the National Guard for “several years” about acquiring the Stevens Avenue Armory.
He said with the guard’s need to relocate and modernize its facilities, now seemed like the right time to move forward with the “mutually beneficial” land swap.
Bola said the guard has received initial funding to build a new readiness center and that’s why the University of New England and the National Guard are now approaching the town of Scarborough with the contract zone proposal.
He said in the past two years, the University of New England has looked at 10 different parcels in southern Maine, trying to find a good fit for the National Guard. After consulting with the guard, the college has signed a purchase and sales agreement for the property straddling the Scarborough and Saco town lines.
Bola said the college’s “sole interest” in the land is the ability to swap it for the Stevens Avenue Armory, which gives the University of New England its only chance to “increase the utility of the existing (Portland) campus.”
The Portland campus is bounded to the south by Evergreen Cemetery and to the east by a well-established residential neighborhood.
If the property swap between the National Guard and the University of New England were to go through, Bola said, the college has no immediate plans for redevelopment of the armory site, other than for parking.
He said acquiring the armory is in the “strategic best interests” of the college, giving it “room to grow” and providing a variety of options to make the whole Portland campus “more usable and accessible.”
Bola called the contract zone proposal that would move the National Guard to Scarborough a “win, win, win,” and said that the guard’s new home could be “an enhancement to the community.”
Prior to the Town Council meeting on Wednesday, Council Chairman Richard Sullivan said that although the guard would not pay any taxes to the town, he could foresee a variety of benefits to having the new readiness center built in Scarborough.
“It’s still early in the process,” Sullivan said this week, “but I don’t see any problems or issues with (the contract zone).”
He also said with its limited access, he doesn’t see the land as being “an ideal spot for too much else” in terms of development.
“I think this would be a good location for the guard. Right now it all looks positive,” Sullivan said, while adding he’s looking forward to hearing what the rest of the council has to say about the proposal.
Bola said he sees the National Guard moving to town as a “great opportunity for Scarborough” that will “enhance the community and provide a development opportunity that might not otherwise be realized.”
Even if the Scarborough Town Council ultimately approves the contract zone needed by the Maine Army National Guard, John Blais, senior planner for the guard, said ground would not likely be broken until spring 2019.
Blais hopes the first phase of the proposed relocation, which includes construction of a new 50,000-square-foot readiness center, would be approved in the 2018 federal budget, but said whether the funding actually comes through would depend on Congress.
He said the relocation to Scarborough would “just replace what we have in Portland,” although Blais admitted that the new site would give the guard a lot more opportunity for growth.
Blais said the idea would be for the new readiness center to also support guard units in Westbrook and Sanford. He said when construction on the readiness center begins, it would likely take about two years.
If the guard does relocate to Scarborough, Blais said the goal would be to also build a 29,000-square-foot vehicle and equipment maintenance facility, but he doesn’t yet know what the timing would be on constructing the maintenance shop.
In the contract zone application, the University of New England and the Maine Army National Guard said that while the readiness center and maintenance shop are not currently allowed in the rural farm zone, the project is consistent with Scarborough’s comprehensive plan and other existed and permitted uses within the zoning.
In addition, as part of the public benefit requirement for a contract zone, the guard has said it would be willing to put 3.5 acres of the land into a conservation easement to be held by the Scarborough Land Trust.
That acreage would abut land already owned by the state as a wildlife management area, according to the contract zone application. Access to the site would be through Saco and no curb cut onto Route 1 in Scarborough would be required, the application states.
The readiness center would house five administrative staff during the normal workweek and provide training and drill space for up to 100 National Guard members during their monthly weekend training.
Once built, the maintenance shop would house 19 full-time employees.
Going into Wednesday’s meeting with the Town Council and Planning Board, Town Planner Dan Bacon said contract zoning is a good tool to use for “very unique developments, projects that don’t easily fit into the town’s zoning scheme or for projects that have a particular public benefit.”
He said contract zoning seems like a “reasonable tool to use” for the National Guard project, but said the ultimate decision about whether to allow it to move forward is up to Scarborough’s governing boards.
Bacon said so far, town staff is most concerned with ensuring that there is an “adequate buffer” between the proposed readiness center and the neighboring properties in Scarborough, as well as to Stuart Brook and the headwaters of Scarborough Marsh.
Assuming the Town Council and Planning Board agree to move forward on the contract zone proposal this week, the next step would be for the Planning Board to provide site plan review and preliminary approval before the project would go back to the Town Council for a first reading, public hearing and a final vote.
Both Bola and Blais said the portion of the 38 acres located in Saco is already under a contract zone that allows a mix of commercial, governmental, professional office and residential development, so there would be no need for anything other than a normal site plan review in that community.
Bacon added, “When considering a contract zone or a proposal for a zoning change, it’s always important to ask, ‘What could be developed there under the current zoning?’ This site is zoned for rural residential development, so a small single-family neighborhood could be developed there next to a contract zone in Saco that allows a wide range of commercial development. A basic policy question (would be), ‘Is that more or less advantageous for this property in Scarborough?’”
The Maine Army National Guard is seeking a contract zone for this 38-acre site, off Route 1 in Scarborough and Saco. The proposal is to build a new readiness center and field maintenance shop.
Comments are no longer available on this story