Travelers in the Sebago Lake region can spend the night – or the month – at a variety of motels, bed-and-breakfasts, cottages and campgrounds.
But on the roughly 50-mile stretch between Westbrook and North Conway, N.H., there’s never been a hotel operated by a national chain.
Now two developers are each planning to build one on Route 302 in Windham, less than a mile apart.
Some say there’s room for both projects, but others believe even one large hotel would put struggling local lodges out of business, saying there’s not enough demand to support the combined 154 rooms that have been proposed.
“It would surprise me if both the hotels would go up,” said Greg Dugal, executive director of the Maine Innkeepers Association. “There’s no question” there would be a negative impact on the smaller motels and inns if both were built, he said.
A study of Maine hotels’ occupancy rates, called the Smith Travel Report, only breaks down figures for the Portland, Bangor and Augusta areas, so no exact occupancy rates for the Sebago Lake region are compiled.
The potential burst of construction in the area comes as Portland is poised to experience its own boom. Three recently proposed hotel projects in the city would add 400 rooms, even though Portland’s year-round occupancy is only around 60 percent. Portland’s rates range from about 40 percent in the winter to more than 90 percent in the summer.
The fluctuation is even more extreme in the lakes region, according to owners of motels along Route 302.
“If I had 200 rooms in the summer, I could fill them for 10 weekends,” said Mark Libby, owner of the 11-room White Pines Inn on Route 302 in Raymond. But the phones stop ringing in August and he sometimes has to forgo his paycheck.
“This single hotel going in, I would venture to say, would be devastating to us,” he said. “A second hotel? I would wait it out until they figure out it’s not going to work for them.”
Both hotels have been talked about for years, but plans were thought to be on hold until both projects appeared before the Windham Planning Board in the past two months.
Erik Heyland, who owns the Microtel Inn & Suites in York, first proposed building a 74-room hotel in Windham in 2007, but the project was hung up first by a state transportation approval and then by the poor economy.
Heyland resubmitted his plan in September and hopes to have his MainStay Suites franchise open in a year.
Martin Lippman’s plan to build a hotel and restaurant was part of a complex deal in which he paid the town to buy 123 acres for a park and, in exchange, would get to use some of the land to offset sewer density calculations for an adjacent development.
The town purchased the land and was reimbursed by Lippman two years ago. Last month, Fred Panico of Planning-Design Associates in Windham brought the board plans for an 80-room hotel, an 80-seat restaurant and a couple of commercial buildings.
Lippman said he’s been in talks with Hampton Inn, and hopes to have a local brew pub move onto the site.
Panico, the project coordinator, said a feasibility study showed that the market would support an 80-room hotel with a function room and indoor pool in Windham.
“To be honest with you, I don’t know if we both can do it, but we’re going as if ours is the only project up there,” he said.
Reached Thursday, Heyland said he had heard a while ago about plans for another hotel, but didn’t know specifically about Lippman’s proposal.
But a Hampton Inn is much different than what he plans to build, Heyland said. His rooms would be less expensive and have small kitchen areas so people could stay one night or live there for several months.
“I think the area’s busy enough” for two hotels, he said. “I’m not terrified about it.”
Alan Aaskov, owner of Alyssa’s Motel on Route 302 in Casco, isn’t scared either.
“I welcome them to come in if they want,” Aaskov said. He has to have a second job to stay in business anyway, he said.
His wife calls his nine-room motel a hobby. But it’s unique and on Thomas Pond, which offers a different experience than a “cookie-cutter” chain with an indoor pool, he said.
“Usually if one car dealership opens and another one opens across the street, both end up selling more cars,” said Aaskov.
That’s how it worked for the Mount Blue Motel in Farmington when a Comfort Inn & Suites was built in neighboring Wilton in 2008, said Kelly Wells, manager of the 18-room motel.
Like the Sebago Lake region, the Farmington area has a college and is on the way to a ski mountain.
“Our prices are a lot lower than the Comfort Inn.… It gives people a choice,” Wells said. “When you give people a choice, more people are out shopping.”
Staff Writer Leslie Bridgers can be contacted at 791-6364 or at:
lbridgers@pressherald.com
Comments are no longer available on this story