This is where your Wal-Mart bag’s life begins: in Elkridge, Md., not far from Baltimore-Washington International Marshall Airport, at a hulking factory the size of three football fields. Millions of bags with blue Wal-Mart logos or red Target bull’s-eyes spin through Advance Polybag’s plant. The operation runs nonstop, every day, even on Christmas.
For the factory’s owners and its 140 employees, producing a useful staple of everyday life represents one version of the American dream. But to environmentalists and some politicians, the millions of bags produced by the plant every day are a plague upon the Earth, fouling rivers, oceans and forests.
Plastic bags have been banned in some parts of the country and taxed in others. Just last month, Maryland lawmakers considered imposing the country’s first statewide bag tax, of 5 cents. The legislation didn’t make it to the floor of the House of Delegates, but proponents promise to push the measure again next year.
“This is coming, one way or another,” said Maryland Delegate Dereck E. Davis, chairman of the state’s powerful House Economic Matters Committee. “The whole idea of free bags is going by the wayside. It’s not a matter of if, but when.”
Such tough talk has the plastic bag industry ready for a long battle against taxes and bans — not just in Maryland but around the country, where dozens of measures are under consideration. The industry’s fear, experts say, is that even though plastic bags account for only $9.8 billion of the $374 billion plastics business, targeting bags could be a starting point for increased regulatory scrutiny against other plastic products, including bottles.
Along with industry trade groups, executives from Advance Polybag and Hilex Poly, another top bag maker, are on the offensive, hiring public relations firms and lobbyists, writing op-eds, backing social media campaigns with titles such as BagTheBan. They complain their views aren’t given a fair hearing by lawmakers and regulators, who often leave their testimony to the very end of hearings.
“Give us a fair debate,” said Bill Ebeck, Advance Polybag’s director of sales, in an interview at the Elkridge plant attended by a representative from Edelman, the New York public relations firm that also represents Wal-Mart. “We can present the truths from the facts, as opposed to the opinions.”
Ebeck recently published an op-ed calling plastic bags “scapegoats,” declaring bags aren’t a major environmental problem and noting that “for the hardest hit families, every nickel counts.”
Plastic bags weren’t always an object of derision. They were patented in 1962 by a Swedish engineer named Sten Thulin, who “devised an ingenious system of folds and welds that made it possible to transform a flimsy tube of polyethylene film into a strong, sturdy bag,” journalist Susan Freinkel wrote in her 2011 book, “Plastic: A Toxic Love Story.”
Back then, the bag was viewed with something like wonder.
“Today the bag is so maligned that we forget what an engineering marvel it is: a waterproof, durable, featherweight packet capable of holding more than a thousand times its weight,” Freinkel wrote.
But it wasn’t an immediate hit. Shoppers “didn’t like the way a checkout clerk often licked his fingers to pull a plastic bag free from the rack, or the fact that the bags wouldn’t stand up,” Freinkel wrote.
After companies showed consumers that a flat-bottom bag wasn’t always needed, plastic bags caught on. Today companies such as Advance Polybag, which is based near Houston, produce millions a day in factories around the United States. By some estimates, consumers use more than a trillion plastic bags around the world every year. Advance Polybag generates about $260 million a year in sales, according to Plastics News.
The problem, according to environmentalists, is that the bags are so light and so bountiful that they frequently fly away from custody, clogging streams and waterways, getting stuck in trees, polluting oceans. That’s one side of the argument, which is pushed not just by environmentalists but also the paper bag industry. In some anti-bag legislation, paper bags have been included with plastics, making paper bag manufacturers angry and defensive.
“The paper bag has been unfairly lumped into the single-use bag category,” said Christopher Klein, environmental manager for Kentucky-based Duro Bag, the country’s largest paper bag maker, whose customers include Macy’s and Dunkin’ Donuts. “Paper bags are much more sustainable and are the better option for the environment.”
The plastic industry, not surprisingly, disagrees. Its side of the argument includes some of these points: Plastic bags are recyclable, bags are often used more than once, they generate less waste than paper, regulatory action increases costs for lower-income consumers and environmental pollution is exaggerated by plastic bag-haters.
The facts, according to the Environmental Protection Agency: “In 2010, the category of plastics which includes bags, sacks and wraps was recycled at almost 12 percent” and plastic bags, sacks and wraps constitute less than 1 percent of the municipal solid waste stream.
SPI, the plastics industry trade group, helps executives push their arguments to politicians around the country through the American Progressive Bag Alliance, a collection of top bag producers. The industry is also active on Facebook, Twitter and YouTube.
And while Advance Polybag employees are concerned about their own status quo, there is some recognition of the opposing side in the debate. Wesley Hughes, a 51-year-old forklift driver at the plant who helps load bags on upwards of 20 tractor-trailers a day, said he was worried about the tax, particularly as a consumer.
But asked whether it ever occurred to him that plastic bags could be controversial, Hughes said, “Sure.”
Why?
“Probably the environment,” he said. “What are you gonna do with all this stuff? Unless you recycle a lot of it, where are you gonna throw it?”
Comments are no longer available on this story