Calling election signs an important part of Maine’s political campaigns, the South Portland City Council refused to support a proposal to ban placards and posters from public property.
Resident Ralph Cabana offered the idea at a council workshop Monday night. He said the city should try to adopt locally a measure Rep. Jane Eberle, D-South Portland, had tried to pass in the Maine Legislature.
Cabana noted the signs clutter median strips and road sides. He also noted the environmental impact, since the temporary signs are thrown away after elections.
Cabana had proposed that campaign signs, which are currently allowed on both public and private property during election season, be restricted to private property only. Under the current rules, there
are no limits on the placement of signs, resulting in hundreds of signs placed in high-visibility areas.
The signs are an eyesore, Cabana claimed. He also said that cleaning up signs after the election is a problem, especially since some candidates don’t bother to remove their signs right away.
But Cabana’s proposal suffered the same fate as Eberle’s bill: The council balked at supporting it.
No official vote was taken at Monday’s workshop. But Councilors Tom Coward, Patti Smith, Jim Hughes and Maxine Beecher said they could not support the proposal.
“I have no love for campaign signs,” Coward said. “But democracy is a messy system. This is part of the traditional way campaigns are conducted in Maine.”
Hughes said he opposed the proposal, because signs are an affordable way for candidates to get their message out. Cutting out signs could force candidates on a tight budget out of the election process, he
said.
Beecher had mixed feelings, but ultimately said that she too would not support the proposal.
Gary Crosby, a council candidate, spoke out against the idea. Crosby called it a potential restriction of freedom of speech. He also said that it would favor a candidate who owns property that is most visible to the public.
“I want fairness for everyone,” he told the council.
Mayor Tom Blake was the only councilor to speak out in support of the measure. Councilors Jim Soule and Linda Boudreau were absent from the workshop.
Blake said that signs are no longer necessary in the age of the Internet.
“Signs are a waste of money and time,” he said.
Blake went on to say that he supports any measure that ultimately force candidates to knock on doors and meet residents face to face. He encouraged Cabana to consider collecting signatures to put the idea before the voters as a ballot referendum or to return to the council with an updated plan that would be less restrictive.
Comments are no longer available on this story