Despite sitting at the heart of Maine’s strong tourism and retail industries, Congress Street in Portland is rife with blank windows and for-lease signs. Portland staples like Renys and HiFi Donuts shut down and neighborhoods are dominated by empty storefronts that never seemed to be filled. That isn’t a coincidence.
When landlords face a vacancy at a retail property they have a choice: fill it with a new tenant or wait. While filling a vacancy and earning more rent as soon as possible might sound like a no-brainer, any Portland resident can tell you that we don’t often see that happen. A 2023 Harvard JCHS study tells us why: entering a new lease is costly for landlords.
Bringing in a new tenant often means spending money to renovate the space, offering free months of rent, but most importantly, it means giving up the possibility of a higher-paying tenant for the duration of the lease. Because retail leases are so long (sometimes surpassing a decade), landlords pass up filling their space in favor of waiting for a more favorable economy or a tenant willing to pay higher rent. Our current system allows such speculation to happen unchecked for years. The result? Empty storefronts dominate an otherwise healthy city.
Retail vacancies are more than just an aesthetic issue. Long-term vacancies means less business; less business means less taxes generated for essential city services and less foot traffic, which makes it harder for other nearby businesses and creates a safety issue at night. Worse, all of these factors can drive down the property value and investment in an area, which then reinforces these factors even more, creating urban decay — a process known as the Urban Doom Loop.
What can confront the rise in vacancies and stop the pattern of store closures? One policy tool that helps is a retail vacancy fee. A vacancy fee would charge landlords of vacant retail spaces periodically for as long as the properties remain empty. Said fees typically scale with the size of the space and increase over time. Essentially, a landlord who keeps their property empty will face increasing fees until they decide to fill it with a tenant.
The fee works by incentivizing landlords to fill vacant properties quicker. With the inevitability of fees on the horizon, holding on to vacancies for speculation becomes far less worthwhile — the potential benefits are outstripped by the actual liabilities. This is a good thing for our communities; fewer vacancies means more business, more foot traffic and more conveniences and amenities for residents.
Opponents of retail vacancy fees typically raise the objection that they don’t address every aspect of a landlord’s decision to keep a space vacant. Indeed, even the aforementioned JCHS study concludes that high lease startup costs are more impactful on prolonged vacancies. The study also notes that in isolation, vacancy fees could cause landlords to select lower-quality tenants that don’t stick around as long. That’s true; fortunately, however, fees are not the only instruments in Portland’s toolbox.
For example, take the recently passed Storefront Improvement Revolving Loan Program, which provides no-interest loans to commercial landlords or tenants to renovate their spaces. These loans make it easier for landlords to host lower-paying (i.e., non tourism-based) businesses by reducing the cost of bringing in new tenants. Add vacancy fees to the mix, and there’s a powerful structure that encourages landlords to bring in and keep businesses that benefit Portland’s communities.
We invite you to add your comments. We encourage a thoughtful exchange of ideas and information on this website. By joining the conversation, you are agreeing to our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is found on our FAQs. You can update your screen name on the member's center.
Comments are managed by our staff during regular business hours Monday through Friday as well as limited hours on Saturday and Sunday. Comments held for moderation outside of those hours may take longer to approve.
Join the Conversation
Please sign into your Press Herald account to participate in conversations below. If you do not have an account, you can subscribe here. Questions? Please see our FAQs.