“No matter how long we get to parent our children, there are only limited numbers of ‘I love yous’ we can say to them,” writes Yiyun Li in her memoir “Things in Nature Merely Grow.” I love you is the parent’s salutation, three parting words uttered via texts, before leaving on trips, at school drop-offs. An utterance so automatic that few of us, Li included, would give much thought to saying it for the last time. We may know the days are coming when our children will outgrow us, but it is beyond us to consider their permanent departure.

“A mother’s job is to provide a framework for living: things to do, places to go, days that never fail to break, and nights that always fall,” Li writes. “A mother dedicating herself to the framework for living is like a shipbuilder building a vessel, not asking if the voyage is to be through calm seas or tempests, not questioning if there will be a tomorrow or not.”
While slicing her sons’ apples, encouraging their hobbies, placating their peculiarities, Li could neither have predicted nor prepared for their untimely deaths. She could not have known, as she said I love you to her youngest son, James, after a Lunar New Year’s dinner, that the framework for living that she had provided would soon become a “framework for memory.” That James would die by suicide in much the same way his older brother, Vincent, had six years, four months and 19 days prior. That the mother of two would go from parenting teenagers to mourning their extraordinary, almost unfathomable, absence.
It’s this absence, an abyss, that centers the brief book. Yet the volume is full of the boys’ presence as Li crafts an ethereal memorial: the eldest who knit and wrote “astonishingly painful” poems at 10, the youngest who became a self-studied polyglot and reread Albert Camus’s “The Myth of Sisyphus,” a contemplation of the philosophical dilemma of suicide, shortly before his death. The boys flit in and out of the story as Li examines their childhoods and choices; she recalls carrying one of them to her classes in Iowa when he was a baby, another in his favorite cafe in Oakland. When a friend recites a poem suggesting we retain only three happy memories, Li begins to compile a list of the joys her children brought her — and soon finds it overflowing.
It is in these recollections that readers might sense a search for greater meaning on Li’s part. When James asks his mother about monophobia — a morbid fear of being alone — is he showing a need for greater support after Vincent’s death? When Vincent asks her, “You understand suffering, and you write about suffering so well; why did you give birth to us?,” is he offering a clue to his internal torment? What should she have answered? Ultimately, it doesn’t matter: “That a mother can do all things humanly possible for her children and yet cannot keep them alive — this is a fact that eschews any adjective.”
This lack of a precise descriptor does not prevent Li from beautifully narrating her nonlinear, never-ending odyssey of pain. Tracing her “new knowledge of reality” — a reference to Wallace Stevens’s poem “Not Ideas About the Thing but the Thing Itself” — Li quietly guides us through the devastation of living, and mothering, after death. “Death, though a hard, hard thing, is not always the hardest thing. Both my children chose a hard thing. We are left with the hardest: to live after their deaths.”
The phrase “Children die, and parents go on living” recurs throughout, emphasizing the tragedy of mundanity after such an enormous loss. To paraphrase Walter Benjamin, that things just go on is the catastrophe. We want to imagine that the whole world stops when our world stops, but the wreckage keeps piling up.
“Death fails to be a black hole in one particular sense: it does not absorb all the time,” Li writes, picking up on a theme that she previously contemplated in “Where Reasons End,” a novel written shortly after her oldest son’s death. “Those who have to live through the days after a beloved’s death and those who are beset by debilitating depression will know this: time stands still, time feels monotonous, and then time becomes Sisyphus’s boulder.”
For Li, carrying on living means piano lessons, gardening, therapy sessions and conversations with friends. Yet it also entails being out in the world with people who can be unimaginably — if unintentionally — cruel: a cashier’s innocent question on Mother’s Day, a visit from a fellow parent demanding to know why her daughter did not receive a goodbye text, the silence of some friends and attempts by others to compare incomparable losses. Even as Li writes, “Anger is not a major or even a minor emotion in my life,” it is hard not to be enraged for her at the heartlessness of others, though she instead assuages the guilt of those who don’t know what to say. “It’s all right not to understand the situation — neither do the parents!” she writes.
As Li notes, we are not obliged to show our suffering to the world: “Very few people in the world deserve our tears.” Instead of a sob story, she delivers an extraordinarily intellectual undertaking that transforms the motherhood memoir, always a fraught genre. Parenting manuals fail us, and mothers can behave in many ways. Mothers can be malevolent — Li’s mother’s words after her grandson’s death are devastating — as readily as they can be loving, caring, respectful. As Li’s experience reveals, no matter how well a parent relates to their child, there are limits to how much love can achieve.
“Yes, I loved them, and I still love them,” Li writes. “But more important than loving is understanding and respecting my children, which includes, more than anything else, understanding and respecting their choices to end their lives.”
A mother, she writes, cannot keep a child alive. In writing like Li’s, however, even absent children can live on.
—
If you or someone you know needs help, visit 988lifeline.org or call or text the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988.
Courtney Tenz writes at the intersection of conflict and culture, covering women’s rights, the arts and European travel.
We invite you to add your comments. We encourage a thoughtful exchange of ideas and information on this website. By joining the conversation, you are agreeing to our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is found on our FAQs. You can update your screen name on the member's center.
Comments are managed by our staff during regular business hours Monday through Friday as well as limited hours on Saturday and Sunday. Comments held for moderation outside of those hours may take longer to approve.
Join the Conversation
Please sign into your Press Herald account to participate in conversations below. If you do not have an account, you can subscribe here. Questions? Please see our FAQs.