5 min read

The newly proposed design of the Marshview Apartments in Scarborough now stands at just 50 units rather than 96. It’s shrunk in other ways, from parking spaces to environmental impacts. Image courtesy of South Portland Housing Development Corporation

“Size,” “height,” “setback,” “traffic,” “wetlands,” “parking,” “the entrance,” “the marsh.”

The reasons Scarborough residents and their municipal representatives opposed the proposed 96-unit Marshview Apartments were bountiful, resulting in its recent failure before the Planning Board and Town Council.

But the South Portland Housing Development Corporation is back with a new proposal influenced by all of that criticism. The original proposal consisted of a four-story building with 60 affordable senior units, plus an additional three buildings with 36 units of workforce housing spread between them.

The new plan calls for just 50 units of affordable senior housing.

“We’ve scaled back the developed area, the parking, the traffic counts, the size of the building, how close it is to the road, its proximity to the marsh and to wetlands,” Ben Mohney, SPHDC’s development officer, said in an interview Friday. “Every single item that was brought up, we’ve addressed.”

Advertisement

THE ORIGINAL PLAN

Plans for the development at the site of the former Southern Maine Flea Market at 578 U.S. Route 1 began forming nearly two years ago, Mohney said. The initial proposal, made in late 2024, took into account a wealth of feedback that developers got from town staff.

“The first input we got was that a combination of affordable senior housing and workforce housing was a need and desire for the community,” he said. “That messaging changed once we got back in front of the planning board.”

The original proposal was to build a four-story, 60-unit building for affordable senior housing. Three other buildings on the site, with 12 units each, would be home to workforce housing. It would have also featured a walking trail and a playground.

Plans show the original proposal for the Marshview Apartments on Route 1 in Scarborough. Image courtesy of South Portland Housing Authority

The entrance — only accessible on the northbound side of Route 1 — was the strongest source of most residents’ opposition. Impeding on wetlands on the back of the property became another concern, along with the senior housing building’s height and proximity to the road, plus the impact on traffic and safety near the busy intersection of Route 1 and Payne Road.

One planning board member described the proposal as “a wonderful concept and a well-laid-out design in the wrong place.”

SPHDC was “cognizant” of some of these factors — especially the wetland impacts — when it initially proposed the 96-unit development, Mohney said.

Advertisement

“That’s why the (senior) building got so close to the road and why the building got as tall as it did initially,” he said. “That was all based on feedback from town staff and peer reviewers.”

CUT IN HALF

The new 50-unit proposal is nearly half its predecessor’s size and addresses most publicly stated points of contention with the 96-unit plan.

There are no impacts to wetlands in the new proposal, whereas the original proposal would have encroached on nearly 13,000 square feet of wetlands.

Only 1.6 acres of the property is to be developed, compared to 4.4 acres in the original proposal, and there are now 55 parking spaces planned rather than 114. The former flea market and its parking lot currently take up more space than the new proposal would if approved.

“We’ll be reducing the footprint of the existing site,” Mohney said. Coupled with better stormwater management and modern environmental standards, he added, “our goal is to make the site better than the way we found it.”

One concern hasn’t fully been resolved: the entrance. SPHDC hasn’t been able to find a way around the right-turn-in, right-turn-out entryway, which remains part of the new proposal.

Advertisement

However, Mohney believes developers have addressed part of that concern: The new proposal’s projected traffic impact is now 13 rush-hour trips per day compared to the estimated 32 per day under the 96-unit design.

OUTSIDE THE CITY

The South Portland Housing Development Corporation is a nonprofit developer under the South Portland Housing Authority.

The authority was born in the 1940s, providing housing for workers at the Liberty Shipyard and managing over 4,000 units. Today, it operates about 800 housing units — apartments, single-family homes, townhouses and more — making it one of the largest housing authorities in the state.

At public meetings, some residents have questioned what the South Portland entity is doing in Scarborough in the first place. Mohney says the South Portland Housing Authority works with other communities that either have small housing authorities or none at all.

“Our mission is to develop safe, high-quality, affordable housing,” Mohney said Friday. “That has no boundaries. It is the mission of our board of directors to help not just South Portland but communities around us.”

The developer already operates Jocelyn Place, a 60-unit senior housing development, in Scarborough, and Biddeford’s housing authority has been a longtime partner as well, Mohney said.

Advertisement

In many instances, when a proposed housing proposal fails, it is difficult for the developer to come back with a heavily altered plan.

Mohney said developers had leeway to make drastic changes because the senior housing and the workforce housing portions of the 96-unit proposal have different funding mechanisms, including grants. That helps the scaled-down proposal to be financially feasible, even with it shrinking the number of units by almost half.

“The senior housing and workforce housing were essentially two different projects,” Mohney said, and one doesn’t rely on the passage of the other. “We wanted to follow the process and be transparent and get community feedback. That’s why we presented both (simultaneously).”

With an application filed, Mohney said he expects meetings with the board and council to ramp up this summer. If all goes smoothly this time around, construction could begin as soon as the summer of 2026 and be finished and ready for move-in by the end of 2027.

Drew is the night reporter for the Portland Press Herald. He previously covered South Portland, Scarborough and Cape Elizabeth for the Sentry, Leader and Southern Forecaster. Though he is from Massachusetts,...

Join the Conversation

Please your Press Herald account to participate in conversations below. If you do not have an account, you can subscribe here. Questions? Please see our FAQs.