3 min read

Andy helped his mother unpack groceries. When he lifted the ice cream carton from the shopping bag, he noticed an announcement in bright red letters on the back of the carton. “Win a Million Dollars for Suggesting a New Flavor to Luna Lakes Ice Cream!”  

Andy laughed. “Look, Mom. I’m going to win by suggesting pickle flavor. That’s what I’d like.” 

 Mom wrinkled her nose. “I don’t think most people would eat pickle ice cream.” 

“If they’re like me they would.” With that, Mom had to agree.  

Andy loved pickles. He liked dill pickles and sweet pickles, half sours and Gran’s crisp bread and butter pickles. He ate them on sandwiches and he munched them as snacks.  He always asked for a fat dill pickle in his lunch.  

Andy invented ways to eat pickles no one else was brave enough to try — peanut butter and pickle sandwiches.  Fried pickles and beef tacos.  Scrambled eggs with pickles. (Even Andy admitted he wasn’t going to try that one again.)  

Advertisement

He quickly read the contest rules. Original. That was the most important requirement. And then, he needed to write a brief statement about the flavor. Andy clapped his hands and wondered what he might do with a million dollars, because he was certain that no one else was going to suggest pickle flavored ice cream. 

Andy shared his idea with Grandpa. “Well, I don’t know,” Grandpa said. “I like pickles all right, but for ice cream, I think I’d stick with chocolate.” 

“Maybe you could think of something to add to ice cream instead,” suggested Aunt Rosalind. “Something everybody likes.” 

Andy frowned. “That’s what I did. I’m adding pickles. People like pickles.” 

“Ah,” said Mom. “But what flavor ice cream are you adding pickles to? I’d think you’d need to say.” 

“And what kind of pickles?” asked Dad. “Sweet? Dill?” 

Advertisement

Andy knew his Mom and Dad  were right.  He had more work to do. He went up to his room to think. 

What kind of pickle? Much as he loved his Gran’s  bread and butter pickles, ice cream was already sweet. “Dill,” he thought. 

Deciding  what flavor ice cream was more difficult.  He quickly eliminated fruit flavors. Vanilla was too plain. Chocolate didn’t feel quite right. Peanut butter? He thought about how much he liked peanut butter sandwiches with pickles.  Peanut butter ice cream laced with pickles sounded perfect.   

Andy only had 30 words to explain his flavor and why it should win. He wrote: Everyone loves ice cream and most people love pickles so I think you should make Peanut Butter Pickle ice cream. Use dill pickles so it won’t be too sweet.  

Andy mailed his entry and the waiting began. He ran to the mailbox every afternoon to see if there was a letter. He checked Luna Lakes’ website to see if  the winner had been announced. For months, nothing happened. 

Then one day, a letter from Luna Lakes Ice Cream arrived, addressed to Andy.  

Advertisement

Dear Andy, it began.  Like you, I love all kinds of pickles and I loved your suggestion for Peanut Butter Pickle ice cream. Our marketing department disagreed and after several studies, we found most people preferred flavors other than pickle. But, I had a batch made for myself and I think it’s delicious. I’m sending you a case by special delivery tomorrow. Thank you for entering Luna Lakes’ contest. 

The letter was signed, Jack Reynolds, CEO, Luna Lakes Ice Cream. 

“Wow!” Andy yelled. “A case of ice cream!” 

“And I’m pretty sure you will be the only one eating it,” laughed Mom and Dad. 

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.