3 min read

The Maine Association for Community Service Providers represents organizations providing homecare and support services to Mainers with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Similarly, the Home Care & Hospice Alliance of Maine represents organizations providing homecare and hospice to elder and disabled Mainers. Both groups, whose members are nearly all not-for-profit, work to ensure that Maine seniors and Mainers with disabilities get access to affordable, quality support in their homes and in the community.  Collectively, our members employ approximately 15,000 direct care workers and serve nearly 30,000 people every year.

We have carefully analyzed Question 1 and stand unanimously opposed to this deeply flawed initiative. Question 1 would violate the privacy of thousands of Mainers, prevent hundreds of millions in federal funding from reaching Mainers in need, and establish more barriers to accessing care.

The violation of patient privacy is one of our biggest concerns. The proposal in Question 1 is contrary to basic principles of federal and state healthcare law. It would be run by a board unaccountable to any state agency, our Legislature, or Maine taxpayers. In order to facilitate elections to this board, the private health information — including names, addresses and phone numbers — of anyone receiving public homecare services would be turned over to organizations campaigning for spots on the board. Maine seniors and Mainers with disabilities would be powerless to stop this.

The care we provide is based upon building the trust of the people we support. Requiring Maine seniors and Mainers with disabilities to give over their private health information in order to receive home-based care will break that trust. Many may even forego a service they desperately need because once that trust is broken, it’s difficult to build it back.

Those who qualify for homecare services through MaineCare are at highest risk for abuse, neglect, and exploitation. People who qualify for this support cannot afford to pay for private healthcare and rely on MaineCare and federal Medicaid funds. Every dollar we put into MaineCare is matched with two dollars in federal funds that goes toward helping Maine people get access to the support they need.

Question 1 relies solely on state taxes. Because there is no income or asset test, it’s ineligible for federal funds. Every one of the $310 million we spend on Question One, we throw away two — a loss of over $600 million in matching federal funds annually that could be used to help people who need it now.

Advertisement

Question 1 would create an entirely separate and duplicative bureaucratic system from the ground up. This will cause confusion and add significant administrative expense. The proposal allows the board to keep $15 million annually for itself. This $15 million would generate $30 million in federal funds if put directly into MaineCare, enough to take hundreds of Maine seniors, children and people with disabilities off waitlists and give them access to the homecare they need now.

Question 1 anticipates insufficient funding and directs its board to “curtail services” and “restrict the total amount of services” when funds run out. This will only create more waitlists. Because federal Medicaid is a payer of last resort, this may create further barriers to homecare available now by requiring exhaustion of Question 1’s waitlists prior to accessing MaineCare.

We are committed to real solutions to get homecare to our neighbors, friends, and family who need it most. We are committed to resolving the direct care workforce shortage. We continue to support and advocate for legislation and funding that will eliminate waitlists, support direct care workers, and give homecare to the people who need it now.

Question 1 will not accomplish any of these worthy goals. We cannot support a program that violates the privacy rights of the very people it claims to help, wastes valuable resources, exacerbates existing shortages, and creates additional barriers without comparable standards of care.

We urge you to vote No on Question 1.

Lydia Dawson is the executive director or the Maine Association for Community Service Providers. Laurie Belden is the executive director Home Care & Hospice Alliance of Maine.

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.