4 min read

WORKERS MAKE THEIR WAY to an early shift at Bath Iron Works.
WORKERS MAKE THEIR WAY to an early shift at Bath Iron Works.
BATH

It’s unclear what impact an estimated $198 million in tax expenditures over 20 years has had on Bath Iron Works. That uncertainty exists as the Legislature’s taxation committee prepares to hold a hearing Tuesday to effectively renew a $60 million tax credit.

In 1997, BIW received a package of tax breaks from both the state of Maine and the city of Bath, evaluated at $198 million.

The purpose of that tax package, according to statements made at the time, was to make BIW more competitive with rival Ingalls Shipbuilding, which received significant funding from the state of Mississippi.

 
 
It’s difficult to determine if the tax breaks had the desired effect.

Advertisement

The original 1997 package can be broken into three parts:

• A tax increment financing agreement with the city of Bath;

• A state exemption under the Business Equipment Tax Reimbursement Program;

• The state’s $60 million Shipbuilding Facility Tax Credit, the effective renewal of which is being undertaken by the taxation committee next week.

No analysis

Beyond the three-part tax package secured in 1997, BIW has taken part in at least one other tax program — Pine Tree Development Zones, which a 2017 analysis found “does not adequately support achievement of any of the program’s desired.” That analysis was performed by the state’s Office of Program Evaluation and Government Accountability.

Advertisement

There has been no comprehensive analysis of the impact of that 1997 package on the shipyard, and there has been limited reporting on each facet individually.

BIW declined to provide data on how much it receives in tax expenditures or what additional programs of which it takes advantage.

However, among tax expenditures made public, BIW received nearly $10 million from local and state sources in fiscal year 2017.

Maine Revenue Services, which oversees the $60 million tax credit, was unable to provide data on how much BIW had received through multiple tax expenditure programs, including the shipbuilding credit. Without that analysis, it is unclear how much of BIW’s investment, employment level or workload is the result of that credit.

Maine Revenue Services data does show that BIW invested some $480 million in the shipyard since then and will receive the full $60 million from the state. It should be noted that under the terms of the 1997 Shipbuilding Facility Tax Credit, BIW was required to invest only $200 million in the shipyard.

However, without any type of analysis, it’s unclear whether those investments were made as a direct result of the tax credit.

Advertisement

It’s difficult to determine whether the credit has made BIW more competitive over the years. Externally, it’s clear that over the last 20 years employment has dropped as the Navy’s demand for warships decreased. BIW was also unable to secure a contract in 2016 to build the next generation of Coast Guard cutters. Those setbacks came despite the shipyard’s massive modernization of their facilities.

Push for oversight

A 2006 OPEGA report on economic development programs in Maine stated that the Shipbuilding Facility Tax Credit had a high-risk profile based on lack of independent review, among other issues.

The only report resembling an actual independent analysis of the tax credit is the Comprehensive Evaluation of State Investment in Economic Development. While the Shipbuilding Facility Tax Credit is only a minor part of that report, the authors suggest that the program should be eliminated or significantly altered to include a broader selection of the shipbuilding community. It does not elaborate on its conclusions.

In more recent years, there has been a significant push in the Legislature to provide more oversight of tax expenditures. In 2015, legislators passed a law that requires regular review of all tax expenditures either by the taxation committee or the government oversight committee.

“The Shipbuilding Tax Credit as well as all other tax expenditure-type items in the state of Maine are now prescribed for ongoing legislative review under a statute based on a bill that was passed” in 2015, said OPEGA Director Beth Ashcroft in an interview on Thursday.

Advertisement

Ashcroft said the tax credit was not scheduled for a full evaluation because it was due to expire.

In an email Thursday night, state Rep. Jennifer DeChant, D-Bath, the author the tax credit renewal, said she has amended her bill so that it will “result in more astute reporting, evaluation and direction.”

“As a member of the government oversight committee, I am keenly aware of the fragmented evaluation and reporting of several state tax incentives,” DeChant wrote.

nstrout@timesrecord.com

CORRECTION: An earlier version of this article stated that the public hearing was Wednesday. It is Tuesday.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.