One of the hardest things for any of us to do is to be objective when we are passionate about something. I get it — I’m one of the most passionate people around.
I care deeply about people, the communities in which I work and making a difference. And I think most people would describe themselves the same way — or at least I hope they would. I hope you live your life with passion.
But sometimes people prey on our passions to take advantage of us, to manipulate us, into believing certain narratives. We don’t want to admit that it happens to us, but it does — we’ve all been victims of it — and we don’t want to admit it because we feel foolish.
We get wrapped up in our passion and we say things that we don’t necessarily mean or we stubbornly hold a stance unwavering even in the light of factual evidence to the contrary. That’s what it means to be objective. The definition of “objective” literally is “not influenced by personal feelings or opinions in considering and representing facts.”
Politics can be a touchy subject. Many chamber executives don’t explore divisive topics. But if all of those equipped to have the meaningful conversations, choose to avoid criticism by forfeiting to engage in the conversations, then no progress can be made.
So below I put across three separate but related ideas. You may be passionate about the central topic, but I ask that you look at it objectively. Try to at least see my point of view, even if you disagree — especially if you disagree.
Let’s start there.
1. It’s OK not to agree.
We used to live in a time when one person held one view of the world and if someone else opposed that view then they would try to convince each other, and if they couldn’t, they would agree to disagree.
More recently, a differing view of the world is met with insults, defriending and alienating that person from others. We’ve become increasingly selective about listening only to insights that reinforce our own views. Sports fandom is about the only place that exists any longer that we agree to disagree yet remain friendly with those we disagree with — and sometimes not even then.
2. Some businesses can’t afford the increased minimum wage.
It’s not popular, but it’s true. Businesses have reported, especially in the more rural areas of Maine, that the jump in 2018 from $9 to $10 could change the way they do business. Next year’s increase to $11 will be more impactful, and the increase to $12 in 2020 has some businesses saying it will drastically change their business model.
Some of you may say, “If they can’t afford to pay a living wage, then they shouldn’t be in business.”
OK, but look at it this way — say you own a ice cream stand in Caribou. Your open seven days per week for four months in the summer, from noon to 9 p.m. You have three people on at all times, and they come in 30 minutes before you open and leave 30 minutes after you close, so you have 210 labor hours per week and 3,570 for the season. At $7.50 per hour, you are looking at $26,775 in payroll costs.
Add in the payroll taxes, cost of the product, marketing, losses, utilities, insurance and rent of the ice cream stand for another $25,000 (conservatively) and you are looking at $52,000 approximately you need to make to turn even a penny of profit. At an average sale of $4 per cone, you need to sell 13,000 cones or a little more than 100 cones per day.
Now with the minimum wage increase, your payroll costs go from $26,775 per season to $42,840 per season by 2020.
Now, if the other costs remain the same — which they won’t with the payroll taxes alone, but even if they did — the business now has to sell 16,960 cones or a little more than 140 cones per day. Forty more cones, per day, every day, is a lot in Caribou.
What if it’s a new ice cream stand? Can they make enough profit to even open the next year? To do that they would need to make twice as much, to cover this year’s and next year’s cost, so they would need 200-280 cones per day. Do you see how that can add up?
The bottom line is, there are many businesses much closer to their bottom line than they would ever let on, and you’ll see some go out of business — some already have. Are our communities and those employees better for those closures?
Conversations are being had in the Maine Legislature about this issue this week, as many small companies are asking for help and bills are being considered to slow down the rate of increase. The wage is not the issue, as much as the rate of increase — it’s too much over a short period of time. A total of $4.50 over four years is the steepest increase to any state or federal minimum wage in U.S. history. There will be casualties for that expediency.
3. Restaurant workers prefer their tips — not just in Maine, but nationwide.
I’m very proud to share this last objective point that one of the newest organizations in the country began from the tip credit fight in Maine last year and has now gone nationwide.
Three Mainers teamed up with other restaurant employees in Washington, D.C., Minnesota and Seattle to combat losing their tips and tip credits and they just began Restaurant Workers of America (restaurantworkersofamerica.org). Regardless of how you think they should feel about being a tipped employee, I encourage you to objectively log onto their website and see what they are saying in their own words.
Their board is comprised of six industry professionals from around the country and they’re finally getting their voices heard.
Be open to new ideas.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less