One of the more frequent questions Legislators heard this past session was “Follow the will of the People” in regards to the recently passed Referendum questions last November. I’ve written previously about the problems that the “Citizen Initiated Referendum” questions pose when used to enact or create laws. We encountered several this past session.
With the passage of four such questions last November, the Legislature found itself trying to implement these laws into a legal framework designed for a more deliberative process, not a conceptual set of ideas that most Citizen Petition are developed around.
Interesting of the 151 legislative districts in Maine, more than 100 didn’t approve of the ballot initiatives and most only won by small margins garnered mostly in the more metropolitan areas of the state. Many legislators, following the will of their people in those districts, could have chosen to not implement the initatives, therefore making compromise amendments necessary.
A law created by the legislative process goes through several steps before becoming law, or failing to become law. A legislative initiated bill is written by staff attorneys in the Revisor’s office before being assigned to the joint committee handling the particular issue the bill focuses on.
A public hearing is set and those who favor the bill, those who oppose the bill and those neither for nor against all get an opportunity to examine, evaluate and debate the pros and cons of the legislation being proposed.
The committee then schedules a work session where the bill receives additional scrutiny including reviews by both the Attorney General’s office, as well as the Secretary of State’s office, for its legal and constitutional review.
Once it passes favorably through the committee it continues to be vetted for its financial impact to the state’s budget, as well as the impact on any agency that may have to administer the new law.
Once it makes it to the floor of the House and Senate it is up for further review and debate before it can actually be passed onto the Executive branch for their blessing or veto. Not an easy process but a thorough analysis on the potential impacts. That is why less than a third of the over 2000 proposed bills ever make it into law.
The Citizen’s Referendum process does not undergo any such scrutiny, it merely has to receive signatures of 10 percent of the number of voters who voted in the last gubernatorial election, and those signatures can come from any area or region of the state, not representative of the cross section of the state that the legislature covers.
The petition must state the essence of the question being proposed and the language of the bill must also be provided. Many people who sign these petitions rarely if ever know the extent of the law they may be signing onto. I’ve actually watched people at polling places being asked to sign a petition without even reading the question, let alone the entire bill. These proposals never go through the public process that most laws are required to receive through the legislative process.
Since 1909 there have been 71 citizen initiative ballot proposals. 39 of them failed at the ballot box, while 32 passed. Of the 32 that did pass, 24 have been changed in the legislative process the following year, including the 4 this past year. Some changes are minor for legal interpretation, while others are substantive for a verity of concerns.
All laws, no matter how they are enacted, whether by legislative action or citizen initiative, can be changed, updated or even rescinded by the Legislature.
This past session of the Legislature dealt with the four referendum questions that passed by changing or amending all four of the laws as passed. As an example the legalize marijuana proposal was some 35 pages long and badly worded, causing many implementations and legal difficulties.
As a result the Legislature has set up a special committee to rewrite the law and to provide stricter regulatory oversight.
The Rank Choice voting question was found to be unconstitutional by Maine’s Supreme Court and thus has very problematic ramifications for implementation. These are but two of the questions we had to deal with and others will no doubt continue to be a source of legislative concerns.
It isn’t that the legislature doesn’t want to “follow the will of the people”, as has been voiced, but when any law, whether by legislative review or citizen’s initiation, is seeking to become law, we need to make sure that what was passed can be lawfully implemented or enforced.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less