SMMC OFFICIAL STANCE ON QUESTIONS 2 AND 4
After surveying the membership, the Southern Midcoast Maine Chamber is urging Maine citizens to vote “no” on Question 2: The 3 percent surcharge on incomes over $200,000.
SMMC works with business owners daily and understands the importance of a quality education. Our students of today are our workforce of tomorrow, and we believe that we always need to provide the best education for our students in Maine. Yet, we do not feel that the solution presented by Question 2 is fair or equitable. In the long run, it drastically hurts the business community in Maine.
• If Question 2 passes Maine would have the highest income tax rate of any state for incomes between $201,000 and $539,000. In recruitment of professionals like doctors, dentists, lawyers and businesses in general, we feel this tax rate would put us at a competitive disadvantage, as several recruiters and industry professionals have told us directly. Only California has a higher income tax rate once you get over the $540,000 threshold, and Maine will remain second nationally.
• Taxing only the highest income bracket is a dangerous precedent and is also unreliable. The over $200,000 taxpayers are the most mobile segment of our economy having the means and capability to move or claim residency elsewhere, making the funding source unreliable.
• Nearly 11,000 of the 16,000 taxpayers in this income bracket are small business owners. The tax would apply to Maine businesses that pass their income through the owner’s individual income tax form, including sub-chapter S corporations and limited liability partnerships. Another tax burden, on top of a possible minimum wage increase and the certainty of the ACA increases and the new overtime rules, it puts Maine at a competitive disadvantage in recruiting and retaining small business owners.
• The distribution model does not make it fair to every part of the state and, although Topsham and Brunswick schools would see direct dollars, Georgetown and West Bath would not. We don’t believe an equitable solution is one that helps some of our communities at the expense of others. Sixty percent of the fund, more than $90 million, goes to 28 school districts/towns, while 85 of the 230 get nothing.
• Although proponents of Question 2 claim that the funds are earmarked specifically for education, the Maine Constitution and a letter from the non-partisan Maine State Office of Fiscal and Program Review explicitly states that there is no way to prevent future legislators from redistributing this fund to whatever they see fit. This is what happened with the casino and lottery money that was “earmarked” for education and now funds several other things.
• Finally, this referendum was developed as a solution to fund the shortfall resulting from a 2003 edict to have state government fund public schools at up to 55 percent. This threshold has not been met by our legislators.
The SMMC supports, rather than adding an additional tax to our Maine businesses, that instead we urge our elected officials to not ignore the 55 percent mandate that was passed in 2003, and to fund our schools to the required level.
If the 55 percent threshold would have been met by our elected officials, then this question would not exist.
Vote ‘No’ on 4
After surveying the membership, SMMC is urging Maine citizens to vote “no” on Question 4: An act to raise the minimum wage.
To be crystal-clear, SMMC is not opposed to a minimum wage increase. However, Question 4 does much more than just add a simple raise to the minimum wage. If passed, it would be the steepest increase to minimum wage in U.S. history, it adds inflation after 2020 so the minimum wage will continually rise, and most importantly, this rule will fundamentally change one of the biggest industries in our tourism-driven state, the restaurant industry, by eliminating the tip credit.
• In a business survey this spring created by local chamber directors, four out of 10 businesses said they may have to layoff current employees if the Q4 passes.
Also, six out of 10 businesses would be less likely to hire new employees.
Respondents to the survey represented 56 different communities across Maine, from 77 different industries.
• No state or federal minimum wage has ever increased $4.50 over four years.
In fact, the $1.50 proposed raise in the first year of the proposal would be one of the 10 steepest increases to minimum wage if that $1.50 increase was spread over four years, instead of one.
• A $12 minimum wage by 2020 will be the second highest in the nation; and fourth highest by 2021, which is where it will stay ranked, assuming inflation doesn’t bring it up to third a few years later.
• Every industry is different, and many states have minimum wage discrepancies based on the industry of the worker. In fact, the tip credit for the restaurant industry is so common that every state east of the Mississippi River has a tip credit of some sort and have for nearly three decades. No state has ever repealed their tip credit because they are so essential and fair. Restaurants like DiMillo’s, Governor’s, Moody’s Diner and Becky’s Diner have all made commercials describing how bad this will be.
• Most restaurants run on a slim margin of between 3-5 percent and new restaurants run even tighter margins at 1-3 percent, if that. An increase from $3.75 per hour to $12 per hour is more than a 200 percent increase in payroll expenses per employee.
• Other factors business owners identified on the survey were:
Devastating to 300,000-plus fixed income seniors who will have no way to afford higher prices on products
Fairness inequality of the “bump factor” to current employees and employers: if the new minimum wage worker makes $12, what do you need to bump existing employees up to, to make it fair for them?
Underemployment: One way for an employer to maintain payroll costs, without firing, is to cut back hours
Automation to replace workers: Selfcheckout grocery lines and restaurant server computers, etc.
Question 4 is a bad solution for Maine businesses.
However, a solution is needed to improving the wages in this state, but not at the expense of our senior citizens and the devastation of our restaurant industry.
Vote no on 4 and let’s encourage our 2017 legislators to work across party lines to come to a more sensible solution that helps the employees and the employers of Maine.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less