Here is where it gets tricky for the citizens.
On all referendum questions, it is important to remember you are not voting on the worth of the outcome to our society, but rather you are voting on the value of the process to reach that outcome.
The difference is staggering.
You are not voting on whether you feel schools deserve more education funding with Question 2. You are voting on whether you think it is fair to put an extra 3 percent tax on business owners who make more than $200,000 so that more schools (but not all schools) can get more funding. I say “business owners” because 11,000 of the 16,000 who will pay this tax are business owners.
Think about “process” in personal terms. Do you buy that expensive suit or dress for the party, when you know you need to buy groceries too? If you do, you buy that new clothing with the full knowledge that you may be short on grocery money. That’s the point. You’re saying, having this outcome is worth the price I will pay later.
My position is that despite the need for education funding and a minimum wage increase, these proposals are not worth what we must pay later. What do they cost us, in my opinion? Jobs. Entrepreneurship. Quality of life for our seniors. An entire generation of youth workers encouraged to work elsewhere. The results are less investments in Maine. Less investments in our region.
If Question 2 and Question 4 pass we have some stark realities to face.
If Question 4 passes, we will be the only state east of the Mississippi without a tip credit for our restaurant servers, forcing restaurants to shut down, cut staff or institute non-tipping policies. Restaurant prices will increase around 25 percent by most industry estimates and many of the best employees will move on.
You will see costs on all products and services go up across the board, which is fine for those still employed, but not so fine for the 300,000 fixed income seniors who won’t be getting a raise to Social Security.
Maine will be the second highest state in minimum wage on Jan. 1, 2020, behind only California who has an economy, literally, 44 times larger than ours.
If Question 2 passes, Maine will have the highest income tax rate for people making more than $200,000 in the country up to $540,000 when we triumphantly fall to second-highest. Our tax rate will be twice as high as Massachusetts, 10 percent higher than New Hampshire, our nearest competitors for recruiting businesses.
For me that is not worth it.
Still some say, “Well at least it’s something!” True, but that’s easy to say when you aren’t the one being taxed. If everyone whose name started with C, J or M had to pay an extra tax next year, it would be great for people whose names start with something else — it doesn’t make it fair.
The “at least it’s something” also speaks to the root cause — the dysfunction in our Legislature. If they could have funded the 55 percent education mandate or agreed on a reasonable minimum wage, we wouldn’t have to be deciding it for them this year.
We elect these people to represent us, and to come to a conclusion that’s best for all. They are not doing that right now. My first piece of advice is to elect people who will reach across the aisle to find common ground, because we can’t have two more years of this.
Secondly, I would say we have a flaw in the referendum process that has never been more visible. The referendum process doesn’t reward compromise among differing sides and a common solution for all. Rather it rewards well financed expediency.
If you have the hundreds of thousands of dollars to hire pollsters, slick marketing people, and have enough left over to endorse certain well-placed legislators in the name of a “campaign contribution,” you can get almost any issue you want on the ballot through referendum.
You need volunteers too, though many of them get paid to “do the right thing” like everyone else on these campaigns. You should get some figureheads in the town who know the most people to get them to sign your petition. Like teachers. If you had teachers across the state stopping parents at hundreds of polling places saying “Hey sign this for education funding. It can help us get thousands of dollars, maybe millions for your son or daughter.” That could work. Oh wait, that’s exactly what the MEA did.
So now we are burdening our fragile business community with more to pay. For the record, no businessperson I have ever spoken to has said they are against education. Every business wants smart local students. No business owner I have ever met has said “I don’t want to pay my employees what their worth. I want them to live in poverty.” None.
If a business can give a raise they will. If not, they will go out of business. That’s what you’re voting on in November.
So let me ask you the questions this way:
Question 2: Do you favor an additional 3 percent tax on business owners which will drive them to the second highest tax bracket nationally, devastating business recruitment with more than 60 percent of the funds going to the largest and often wealthiest 12 percent of Maine school districts while nearly one-third of Maine towns get $0?
Question 4: Do you favor raising the minimum wage to the second highest in the country by 2020, crippling the restaurant industry (a leading segment of our tourism industry), with the highest tipped server wages east of the Mississippi River, while also raising the prices of products across the board and making it particularly difficult for 300,000 fixed income seniors to live and difficult for youth workers to find a job at all?
How would that vote turn out?
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less