A lawsuit against the city of Westbrook was dismissed last week after a federal judge ruled that the police department did not violate the constitutional rights of a Westbrook couple when evicting them from their apartment in 2013.
The couple, Kevin McBride and Anne Blake, had been living on the second floor at 277 Main St., when they were issued criminal trespassing orders by the police department.
U.S. District Judge D. Brock Hornby, who issued his findings Sept. 4, had previously ruled against Blake, stating that the building’s landlords had legally evicted her for not paying rent. However, landlords Marc and Amie LeClerc had not filed an eviction notice for McBride.
The lawsuit, which stated that the no-trespassing order denied McBride his 14th Amendment rights, was filed on behalf of the couple by Pine Tree Legal Assistance and the American Civil Liberties Union of Maine.
A jury trial determined McBride also should have been considered a tenant, but according to testimony from former Westbrook Capt. Tom Roth, Roth did not know McBride was a tenant when giving the order to serve the notices.
Hornby ruled that because neither Roth nor the acting officers set department policy, the city is not liable for the police department’s decision to issue the trespass notice.
McBride said the department should have “conducted a further investigation once he told police he lived there.”
The court decision states that after obtaining eviction papers for Blake, Amie LeClerc asked the police department to issue a no-trespassing notice. LeClerc also said she had “reason to believe” that there “may be at least two other people in the apartment.” However, according to court documents, “LeClerc had no discussion with Capt. Roth about serving trespass notices on anyone other than Blake.”
The court documents reveal that the officers were told to hand out trespass notices to anyone at the apartment.
According to court documents, McBride and Blake borrowed money from friends and family to stay at the nearby Motel 6, but left roughly a month later after running out of funds. The couple gave their dog to an animal shelter, and began tenting in the woods.
According to an Aug. 1, 2013, article in the American Journal, Bill Baker, Westbrook assistant city administrator and former police chief, said the city was being “unfairly targeted” for a perceived wrong relating to the statewide use of so-called “no-trespass orders.”
Comments are no longer available on this story