With the beginning of October comes the start of conference play in college football, otherwise known as the clarity stage ”“ when the big-time teams start to separate, wins are harder to come by and the vision for the national championship picture starts to take shape.
That also means the endless debates about who exactly should be in the running for the national championship, an annual shouting contest that often ends with more controversy than anything else.
This season, we at last seemed destined to get a new system, meant to appease everyone. But of course, the yelling, the noise and the debating has only taken on a new, more ridiculous form.
But more on that later.
First, some history: Over the past 15 years, the debate has centered around determining the top two teams in the country under the selection system known as the Bowl Championship Series, a combination of polls (both of media members and coaches) and computer selection methods that narrowed the field to the two most-deserving teams in the country, who then played in a national championship game.
The BCS was an oft-maligned, heavily ridiculed formula, more for its natural limitations than its true faults: With several teams from different conferences across the country having legitimate claims for being in the national championship game, the BCS had the often impossible task of choosing just two of those teams for the one big game.
Many times, that led to one or more teams being left out, and a resulting outcry from the aggrieved parties that is still ongoing and will last generations after we’re gone: Fans of Auburn University will always believe that they should have been in the 2004 championship game, much as fans of Southern California claim the 2003 national championship as their own, despite the fact that Oklahoma and Louisiana State played in the actual national championship game. These are but two examples of disputed national championships that inevitably have engulfed the sport on a yearly basis.
But despite those limits, the BCS was a marked improvement than the selection systems that came before it, byzantine and outdated systems that often led to split national championships between two teams; the BCS’s best quality was its attempt to place the top two teams in one game at the end of the season to determine a true national champion, something that had never happened before.
Now, after 150 years of college football, there has been another improvement, as we finally have what fans have wanted for so long: a playoff. Beginning this year, a selection committee of 13 will determine the top four teams at the end of the regular season. These four teams will play national semifinals, with the winners playing a national championship game.
While a playoff may seem like a “Well, duh!” idea for most, considering that the Division I Football Bowl Subdivision was the only NCAA-sponsored sport without an officially organized NCAA tournament to determine its champion, it counts as a certifiable revolution in college football.
For years, numerous FBS conferences have express-ed their unwillingness to participate in a playoff system due to the traditional year-end “bowl system,” in which teams with winning records are invited to season-ending games at neutral sites across the country, usually in warm-weather areas. A playoff, it was thought, would ruin that system.
Now, those conferences and the school administrators who lead them have finally given in to the public’s desire for a playoff to better determine a national champion. But that hasn’t stopped the controversy, of course.
Instead, the debate has taken on a new form ”“ four teams, apparently, isn’t enough. Instead, people want there to be eight teams invited into the tournament, or possibly even 16.
The more the merrier is the philosophy ”“ or should I say philo$ophy ”“ and the more teams invited to partake, the harder the road for the team that wins it all, and, as a result, the truer the champion they are.
However, this muddies the true greatness of college football, and the thing that makes it unique ”“ the importance, and the magnitude, of the sport’s four-month regular season.
Unlike other sports ”“ such as the NFL ”“ every game in college football matters. One loss, and certainly two, and it’s curtains for a team’s national championship hopes. That means that every game is vitally important, and lends a sense of urgency to every college football Saturday that the NFL Sundays ”“ where teams can lose half their games and still make the playoffs ”“ don’t possess until very late in its season.
With four teams in the college football playoff, that sense of urgency is still there; with eight, it would be gone. With four teams, there will inevitably be at least one ”“ and possibly three or four ”“ teams that make the playoff with one loss; but with eight teams making the tournament, winning every game wouldn’t seem so necessary, and teams with two and possibly even three losses would still make it.
Sorry, but a team with two or three losses being named the “national champion” would cheapen the whole exercise, especially a regular-season that, unlike in every other major American sporting league, is just as good and sometimes better than the postseason.
As great as March Madness is in college basketball, 68 teams making the postseason tournament have rendered the regular season moot and close to irrelevant, a road college football cannot travel down.
Bigger is often better in sports, but not in this case. We finally got a playoff in college football to determine the national champion. Let’s not make it meaningless by adding more and more teams into the mix, belittling the whole process and the sport in general.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less