3 min read

In a state where more than seven in 10 households use oil as their primary home heating source, something’s gotta give. Governors in New England and the region’s energy officials say the answer to this problem lies in expanding access to natural gas.

It is a “cleaner” and cheaper solution, but the questions remain.

A fight is brewing between the Conservation Law Foundation and the Industrial Energy Consumer Group, along with two labor unions, because the environmental group is concerned about ratepayers footing the bill for the construction of pipelines that would deliver the natural gas to consumers, according to a recent Associated Press report.

The foundation’s senior attorney, Greg Cunningham, said environmentalists have long urged an expansion of natural gas as a cleaner alternative to oil- and coal-fired plants, and it continues to stand by that opinion, but the group has concerns about how energy policy is being coordinated by the group of governors. He said state leaders are conducting private negotiations with the energy industry, and environmentalists have submitted public records requests to get more information about what’s going on behind closed doors, according to the AP report.

On the other side, Anthony Buxton, a Portland-based lawyer representing the Industrial Energy Consumer Group and unions, has taken issue with the Conservation Law Foundation’s stance and made a complaint with Maine utility regulators. Buxton said the foundation has promoted the construction of natural gas plants in New England, and then tried to block pipeline projects.

Advertisement

While those parties fight out their issues, the fact remains that Maine is in serious need of more and better energy solutions, and it would be poor policy and planning to put all of our eggs in one basket.

It is important that Maine increase its access to and use of natural gas, as it is “cleaner” than heating oil ”“ a petroleum product ”“ with an ever-rising price. How-ever, natural gas is not a renewable resource, because it cannot be replenished on a human timeframe, according to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

Natural gas may be called “cleaner,” because although the burning of it produces nitrogen oxides and carbon dioxide, it is in lower quantities than burning coal or oil, according to the EPA.

The main reason officials want to pursue using more natural gas in New England is the cost.

The U.S. Energy Information Administration is predicting that most Americans will pay more to heat their homes this winter ”“ but with a major disparity in the cost depending on the type. For homes heated with natural gas, the average total cost will be $679 this winter, while homes heated primarily with heating oil are projected to spend, on average, a whopping $2,046 this season, according to the EIA.

While lowering costs is important, it is equally important that the state continue to develop and expand upon energy resources that are actually renewable, namely wind and solar power. In addition, efforts to improve energy efficiency are necessary in a state with a history as long as Maine’s, in which many homes are more than 100 years old. Tax credits and low-interest loans that encourage homeowners to improve insulation and heating equipment will help reduce the energy used, while also providing a cost-savings for those homeowners.

The real key to a brighter future for energy in Maine is diversity.

— Robyn Burnham Rousseau is city editor in the Journal Tribune newsroom.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.