SCARBOROUGH – The Scarborough Sanitary District trustees are not a group known for eliciting headlines. However, the group has two items on its docket that could land the district in court, albeit as plaintiff.
One battle involves a $14,300 bill sent to the Maine Veterinary Referral Center on Technology Way in the Scarborough Enterprise Business Park for exceeding its contracted sewage capacity. The other revolves around the Clambake Restaurant on Pine Point Road, which district officials say dumps grease from its kitchen directly into the sewer system.
According to district Superintendent David Hughes and trustee Chairman Jason Greenleaf, both issues, if left unaddressed, could spread the construction and maintenance costs out to more than 4,500 customers, who already saw a 20 percent increase on residential service voted in last October, driving annual bills from $330 to $396. Those new rates are just now coming effective in quarterly billing for the district, which has run an operational deficit for the past five years.
Wrangling with the veterinary center pertaining to a $14,299.97 bill began after the building’s sewage flow increases from a contracted cap of 615 gallons per day to 1,646. The flow actually spiked three years ago, said Hughes, when the facility changed to a 24/7 operation from a regular weekday schedule.
The original developer had purchased the 615 gallon-per-day flow limit, which the center met during its first two years of operation. The one-time assessment for the increased usage, which is on top of the center’s regular use bill, is put into a reserve fund for use if total usage exceeds the district’s total capacity of 2.5 million gallons per day, forcing a build-out of the treatment plant.
“At some point in time we would need to increase our infrastructure and if we don’t collect that money from the people who are causing that capacity to be used up, the rate payers will have to pay for that work,” said Hughes. “The capacity reserve fee was instituted to protect the current users.”
“The simple matter is the public would take the hit for that, if the new business was not,” said Greenleaf.
The district’s capacity reserve fund has $1.97 million.
An April 30 letter from the center’s attorney, Matthew Libby of Portland law firm Monaghan Leahy, declined the charge, known as a capacity reserve fee.
“Their stance is that the district made an error in the calculations, so it was not their problem,” wrote the district office manager, Sandy Kempton, in the group’s May 22 minutes.
Hughes reached out to say that the numbers actually came from the center’s own engineering reports, when its expansion was approved, and not from anything generated by the sanitary district. Libby authored a June 10 email to the sanitary district’s attorney Paul Frinsko, of Bernstein Shur, offering to settle for $2,500.
“Obviously, we are not in a position to negotiate fees,” said Hughes, at the district’s June 27 meeting, adding that the bill had been resubmitted, with a July 15 due date.
A payment plan was offered with the first attempt to collect the reserve fee, four months ago, said Hughes.
“We tried to be understanding that this is not something that’s in their budget plan,” he said.
In his June 10 email, Libby argues that while his client was made aware of the potential of a capacity reserve fee if it ever exceeded the 615 gallon-per-day flow limit purchased with the original park development, “This does not appear to be a condition the board of trustees actually reviewed and approved when the permit request [for the new building] was presented to them.
“As a result, Maine Veterinary feels as though a fairness argument could be made on both sides,” wrote Libby, adding that his client “is hoping to resolve this dispute without litigation.
“The costs, financial and otherwise, could be significant for both parties,” wrote Libby.
While sanitary district trustees seem willing to let the dispute with the veterinary center go where it will, they are using kid gloves when it comes to the Clambake.
The fact that the restaurant has no grease trap came to light about 18 months ago, when it experienced a sewer backup. Hughes said the district wrote the Clambake’s owners at that time telling them to install a trap as soon as possible.
“At the time, it was the beginning of their season,” said Hughes. “And we were sensitive to the fact that it’s a big expense. I’m not in the business of trying to run businesses out of town. I want to work with them.”
“We don’t want to put a cramp on local businesses,” agreed Greanleaf. “We are, however, bound to make people abide by our policies. If we don’t do that, it could be the public that’s affected.”
In addition to causing sewage blockages, Hughes said, too much grease allowed into the sewer system could cause a sewer overflow, or clog up the “wet well” tanks in various pump stations, which push sewage to the treatment plant near Prout’s Neck.
One issue for the Clambake, said Hughes, is that all of the kitchen waste flows into the same pipes into which the bathrooms discharge, all of which are encased in concrete under the building, in shallow area with a high water table.
“They’ve got a very difficult situation to figure out,” said Hughes, saying to do the job right will probably mean shuttering the restaurant for a time. “I would say since the beginning of this season we’ve been in constant communication. They’ve been pulling their hair out trying to figure out what to do.”
However, the patience of some trustees appears to be wearing thin. At the group’s May 22 meeting, trustee Rob McSorley suggested that “legal action might be needed” if Clambake owner Kevin Thurlow did not have plans in hand by the June 27 meeting.
That did not happen.
The problem, Hughes told trustees, is that the contractor hired to scope the Clambake’s sewer lines with a remote TV camera found a complex of pipes “completely different” from what the restaurant has in its plans.
“They were supposed to have a plumbing plan to me this week, but they’re back to square one,” said Hughes. “They may have to have small, localized, mechanical-type grease traps because of how their plumbing arrangement is.”
“They were given over a year to do this and it hasn’t occurred,” said McSorley. “I wish there was a little more effort on resolving the issue from their end.”
“I don’t have a plan at this point in time,” said Hughes. “As long as they are doing something to deal with the problem, as long as they’re moving forward, I’m happy to give them the appropriate amount of space. But, ultimately, I work for the board, and if the board says enough is enough . . . “
“We trying to work with them, we’re not trying to be hard guys,” said Greenleaf, acknowledging that the town never noticed the lack of grease traps during any of the restaurant’s many expansions and renovations over the years. “The answer to when enough times has passed is subjective at this point. Any enforcement action will have to be a group decision of the board.”
Neither Thurlow nor Clambake manager Don Roth could be reached for comment.
Comments are no longer available on this story