An interesting legal battle is brewing in New Hampshire that could have a significant impact on boys and girls high school athletics.
Shelby Herrington, a hockey player at Bishop Brady High School in Concord, N.H., has played on the boys team for the past few seasons, but the New Hampshire Interscholastic Athletic Association is telling her that she must now join the newly formed girls team that combines Brady Bishop and Trinity of Manchester.
Her parents are fighting for an injunction to block the decision and are arguing that she deserves to play on the boys hockey team.
The case should be pretty simple, however, as the NHIAA’s bylaws prohibit boys and girls from competing on the same teams unless there is an extreme case. When Herrington’s high school didn’t have a girls team, it made sense to allow her to play with the boys squad since she shouldn’t be denied an opportunity to play a sport because her school didn’t have a girls program.
Now there is a girls team, and Herrington should join that squad. Allowing her to stay on the boys team would set a bad precedent that could damage girls sports programs. If top female athletes were allowed to leave their girls teams to play on boys squads, that would weaken girls teams and girls sports programs. Allowing girls to join boys squads could also lead to girls programs being cut because of diminishing numbers, which would set back the 40-year effort to gain equality in sports between boys and girls.
When Title IX was adopted in the 1970s, it was designed to level the playing field and provide the same athletic opportunities for girls that the boys enjoyed. Allowing Herrington to remain on the boys team when there is a girls squad flies in the face of Title IX’s purpose and meaning.
Girls have made great strides in the past 40 years as the athletic opportunities have leveled. Go to any high school gymnasium around Maine, and one will see highly competitive girls teams that are equal to the boys squads in terms of fan interest. Check out a local sports section and one will see that girls sports are given the same coverage as boys teams.
This was not the case prior to Title IX, when many girls either didn’t have an option to play a sport, or their teams were under-funded in favor of boys programs.
We understand that the new girls hockey team in New Hampshire probably won’t be very good, as it’s just getting started, but that’s no excuse for Herrington to not join the club. High school sports are about individuals learning and developing into better people. It teaches children how to work as members of a team, commitment and good sportsmanship. It is not about winning.
A girls team made up of inexperienced players who are new to the sport won’t be as competitive, for sure, but a lot of athletes play for high school teams that do not have winning records. They are not allowed to simply jump ship and play for another team.
Let’s hope the NHIAA decision is upheld, as that is the right decision in this case.
Ӣ Ӣ Ӣ
Today’s editorial was written by Sports Editor Al Edwards on behalf of the Journal Tribune Editorial Board. Questions? Comments? Contact Managing Editor Kristen Schulze Muszynski by calling 282-1535, Ext. 322, or via email at kristenm@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less