5 min read

There’s a lot of talk around York County about “the list” these days. Everyone has been speculating about who will be identified as alleged “johns” in connection with the prostitution business that was allegedly being operated out of the Kennebunk Pura Vida studio, where Alexis Wright taught Zumba lessons. Could there be public officials on it ”“ lawyers, police officers, journalists?! ”“ the rumor mill has been spinning wildly throughout York County.

The first of those charges were released late Monday, and in our haste to break the news, we published the names in our online edition. We had made a decision that we would publish the names of those charged in connection with the investigation into the alleged prostitution operation, just as we did for Wright, who has pleaded not guilty to 106 counts in relation to the alleged business, including multiple counts of violation of privacy, engaging in prostitution, evasion of income tax, and a count of theft by deception. She was the second person to be publicly charged in relation to this investigation, with the first being a Thomaston man, Mark Strong Sr., who has pleaded not guilty to multiple counts of promotion of prostitution, a count of conspiracy to promote prostitution and multiple counts of invasion of privacy.

We hadn’t anticipated that Cumberland County Superior Court Justice Thomas Warren would release only the names of those charged and not their ages and addresses. When that decision came down, we didn’t change our approach and we published the names of those charged just the same. Such is the immediacy of the Internet, but now that we’ve had time to think it through, we don’t believe those names belong in our paper.

The criminal charges against adults that arise from the investigation, including names, ages and addresses, are public information, by law. If you are charged with a crime, you can expect to have your name and information in the police arrest log, which is published by many newspapers and available to anyone who wants to see it.

The problem with Justice Warren’s decision is that it provides only names for those who have been charged, so anyone who shares that name ”“ from a teenager in Wiscasset to a middle-aged father in Wells ”“ would have only his word to say, “It wasn’t me” to his employers, friends, cohorts and family. As well, the issue of fairness arises, as those people who have more unique names are easily identifiable, and those with more common names are not.

Advertisement

The names of those charged are readily available through the Kennebunk Police Department, either on their website or at the station, but we don’t believe they belong in this paper. We feel that Justice Warren’s decision was irresponsible and puts an inappropriate burden on those who happen to share names with the people who are charged. The ruling was made to withhold full identification because some of the men facing charges are also alleged to have been victims of invasion of privacy, as their purported interludes with Wright were allegedly taped without their knowledge. But they are charged with a crime in their own right, and we believe their full identities should be given ”“ if for no other reason than to protect the innocent.

When we have enough information to provide full identification of those who are facing charges of engaging in prostitution, we will release those names, but we do not feel it is prudent at this time.

Let’s be clear: There has been talk that part of the evidence gathered against Wright and Strong includes a list of her alleged clients. As this case goes forward in the court system and more detailed information is released, that list may be made public.

We don’t intend to publish any “list.” A bunch of names found in a “little black book” is not fair game for publication, in our opinion. If enough evidence has not been found against a person to charge him or her with a crime, it would be irresponsible to identify them as being a possible “john.”

With full ID, however, the arguments against publication of the names of those charged hold no water and skew toward promotion of censorship. Will release of the names of those charged hurt them and their families? Possibly, but so too does the release of the names of those charged with operating under the influence, domestic violence, theft, criminal speeding, etc”¦ The list goes on and on.

To have a court grant a criminally charged defendant the right to withhold their identification from public record would set a disturbing precedent against freedom of information. Where would this slippery slope end? Most likely with the shutting of doors that have previously been open to the sunlight of public information.

Advertisement

We acknowledge that it’s embarrassing and damaging to be charged with a crime. You can lose your job, your friends, the respect of your family and community. No one is disputing that.

All of those considerations, however, are moot after one is facing criminal charges. Once the deed is done ”“ or at least once there is enough evidence to bring charges ”“ it’s public information, however hefty or minor.

People have a right to know what their publicly funded police department is doing and what kinds of crimes are being prosecuted in their area, as well as who is charged with those alleged crimes. It’s not about prurient interest, schadenfreude or sensational journalism, it’s about your legal right to know the details of what’s going on in your community.

It’s not our job to judge whether or not soliciting prostitution should actually be legal, or to say we should let it slide because it’s such a minor, misdemeanor charge. It’s our job to share public information and put it in context for our readers ”“ and that’s it.

It is also worth noting that the charges are just that ”“ charges. Everyone is innocent until proven guilty in our legal system. Being charged with a crime does not mean you did it. Being convicted of a crime does.

We will publish the charges once we have full identification, not the list, because the public has a right to know.

Advertisement

Ӣ Ӣ Ӣ

Today’s editorial was written by Managing Editor Kristen Schulze Muszynski, representing the majority opinion of the Journal Tribune Editorial Board. Questions? Comments? Contact Kristen by calling 282-1535, Ext. 322, or via email at kristenm@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.