For those who think our health care system is fine as it is, a wake-up call has just been issued. The inequity and unfairness of the nation’s health care options is glaring in a Massachusetts judge’s ruling on Tuesday that requires the state to pay for a convicted murderer’s sex change surgery.
Robert J. Kosilek, now known as Michelle, was convicted of murdering his wife in May 1990. He’s serving a life sentence with no possibility of parole.
Kosilek has been undergoing treatment for gender-identity disorder, but sued the state in 2005, saying that sex-change surgery was needed. According to reports, Kosilek has attempted to castrate himself and to commit suicide during his incarceration.
Now the taxpayers of Massachusetts, per the judge’s ruling, will be on the hook for at least $20,000 to pay for this convicted murderer to have the surgery.
While the Constitution does not guarantee health care, much of Kosilek’s case is based on the 8th Amendment, which prohibits cruel and unusual punishment for inmates.
We feel that’s a stretch. Cruel and unusual punishment would have to come from the state itself, such as keeping an inmate in freezing conditions, starving or beating them. Withholding treatment for a life-threatening condition, such as heart disease or cancer, would also fall under such punishment.
It was argued that Kosilek’s gender-identity disorder is life threatening because living in a man’s body is causing him depression to the point of suicide, but Kosilek is getting treatment for his disorder. If an inmate decides to commit suicide or self-mutilate because of their mental state while in jail, that does not qualify as cruel and unusual punishment at the hands of the state. Being a man is not a life-threatening condition in and of itself.
Transgender advocates are hailing this as a boost to their cause, since the opinion argues that the operation is medically necessary for Kosilek, but until it’s deemed medically necessary for all who are insured, this is a slippery slope for publicly funded institutions. What of the inmate who is suicidal because he cannot get a nose job, for example, or any other procedure currently deemed “elective” by the insurance companies? There are many that aren’t covered and are not life-threatening in and of themselves. Where will we draw the line?
The struggles of the transgendered should not be marginalized ”“ and, indeed, they should be more outraged than anyone by this ruling. Hardworking, law-abiding people who feel they were born as the wrong sex have to endure the mental anguish of their identity crisis every day. Many of those who might find comfort in a sex change likely cannot afford the $20,000 or more for the surgery, the ongoing hormone treatment and counseling that it entails. So they live in what they feel is the wrong body their entire lives, many struggling with depression and anxieties related to their situation.
Why should a convicted murderer be granted this life-changing surgery for free when so many others who might want to have the surgery, and are contributing to society, are denied it unless they go heavily into debt?
It’s simply unfair.
When it gets to the point that you get better medical treatment in jail than you do even as a full-time employee with an insurance plan, it’s time to rethink the system. Most would prefer to get the best benefits through reform rather than through incarceration.
Ӣ Ӣ Ӣ
Today’s editorial was written by Managing Editor Kristen Schulze Muszynski, representing the majority opinion of the Journal Tribune Editorial Board. Questions? Comments? Contact Kristen by calling 282-1535, Ext. 322, or via email at kristenm@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less