3 min read

Consumer protection took a hit recently, as the Legislature voted to uphold Gov. LePage’s veto of a bill that would have made the foreclosure process more fair for homeowners. In the wake of the housing bust that hit our economy only a few years ago, one would think our leaders in Augusta would be more inspired to put protections in place for the consumer, but they instead voted on the side of the big lenders.

The bill, LD 145, would have given homeowners the right to request evidence of the original mortgage note within 90 days after the foreclosure proceeding was begun. It was Rep. Bobbi Beavers, D-South Berwick, who sponsored the bill, and she did so in response to the extensive foreclosure fraud nationwide.

The veto is an “open invitation to fraud in Maine,” she said.

We agree.

It seems common sense that a person would want proof that the company foreclosing on him or her is the company that actually holds the mortgage. Unfortunately, that isn’t always the case. The mortgage industry is a mess, with mortgages regularly bundled, sold and traded multiple times. The record keeping hasn’t been stellar, as found in several news reports of people who have wrongly faced foreclosure, and it seems the least that should be required is for the entity seeking to foreclose to be required to prove upfront that they have rights to the property.

Advertisement

While it’s true that we already have laws in place to handle foreclosures, Beavers said she took up this issue because the only provision that allows homeowners to request proof of the mortgage exists in Maine civil procedure rules, not in law, so many people don’t know about it. Homeowners can be drawn through the expensive legal process without the assurance that the lender has the proper paperwork in hand to pursue it, and allowing extensions for the company to find the document causes delays in the process.

The lost money and stress of having to defend your home in a foreclosure process against an entity that doesn’t even hold the mortgage is a nightmare ”“ one that’s unfortunately come true for some people.

In LePage’s announcement of his veto to the Legislature in late March, he said the bill would not shorten the foreclosure process and would instead add a new burden on lenders to “produce original copies of documents or swear under penalty of perjury why they are not able to.” In LePage’s opinion, this would just create more paperwork and won’t help safeguard consumers any more than the current laws on the books.

The bankers also didn’t like the bill, of course, and warned that it would have placed further delays in the already lengthy 420-day foreclosure process in Maine, thereby bringing values down in nearby homes. But it’s hard to believe that it will be a hardship to dig out the mortgage document, which they need to present anyway, within the first 90 days. That document should be in hand before foreclosure proceedings even begin. In fact, this bill could have helped shorten the foreclosure process by making sure that the entity doing the foreclosure was the one that actually holds the mortgage.

We hope this issue has more success when it comes up again ”“ Beavers intends to resubmit it, perhaps with fines included for unscrupulous lenders, if she gets re-elected. Some states have fines as high as half a million dollars, she said, and others even have jail time. With such provisions added, she may have more luck with the governor next time around.

Ӣ Ӣ Ӣ

Today’s editorial was written by Managing Editor Kristen Schulze Muszynski on behalf of the Journal Tribune Editorial Board. Questions? Comments? Contact Kristen by calling 282-1535, Ext. 322, or via email at kristenm@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.