PORTLAND — Nearly every day, I take a walk on the Eastern Promenade.
No matter the weather, it’s spectacularly beautiful.
I often snap photos as I walk. Many of these pictures feature the majestic evergreens near the bandstand at Fort Allen Park – sometimes heavy with snow, sometimes dark green against a summer-blue ocean, and, on rare occasions, silhouetted by a rising full moon.
Often these trees perfectly frame views of Fort Gorges, the islands, or ships entering the harbor.
Planted in 1920, the evergreens are older than most of us.
But their days will be numbered if a proposal put forward by the Friends of the Eastern Promenade is approved.
A public hearing on the plan, known as the Fort Allen Restoration Project, will be held Thursday evening at the East End Community School.
The goal of the project is to restore Fort Allen Park to the way it looked around 1900, shortly after the bandstand, scenic overlook and carriage drive were built.
There’s much to like about the proposal.
Friends of the Eastern Promenade plans to bring back a missing footpath, reconstruct cobblestone gutters along the driveway and restore the Civil War-era cannons and 1814 earthwork berms, both remnants of the park’s previous life as a fortification point protecting Portland’s harbor.
I’m a strong believer in historic restoration, but it requires a careful balance of bringing back original features, while also accommodating subsequent changes that are themselves part of the history of a building or landscape.
The Fort Allen Restoration Project recognizes this balancing act in some respects.
It does not call for the removal of the USS Portland Memorial, which was added to the park in 1949, or the 9/11 memorial, which was added in 2003.
Nor does it suggest demolishing Portland House, the looming high-rise that has been casting shadows over the park since it was erected in 1969.
But there is no similar deference granted to the evergreens.
On its website, Friends of the Eastern Promenade describes the trees as “overgrown” and “having lived out their useful life.”
That is not, in fact, the case.
The trees are fine. Their only failing is that they are not original to the park and do not fit the restoration project’s particular Victorian aesthetic.
According to Portland Parks Commission records, the evergreens were added to Fort Allen Park in 1920.
Park officials planted similar groves in Deering Oaks and along the Western Prom at about the same time, with the aim of creating a more rustic and pastoral feeling in some of the city’s parks.
Even though the trees fall within what Friends of the Eastern Promenade has designated as Fort Allen Park’s “period of historic significance” – the years 1890 to 1930 – the group still wants to cut them down because they are not the sort of landscape features that the Victorians would have planted when the bandstand was built in the 1890s.
At more than 90 years old, the evergreens ought to qualify for historic preservation.
It’s a shame to sacrifice these trees in the service of a narrow historic ideal, one that can never be perfectly achieved anyway.
And it’s a bad precedent for the city’s parks.
If we cut down trees every time there is a new vision for one of our parks, then we’ll never develop the centuries-old trees that should be a central feature of Portland’s greenspaces.
Leaving the evergreens alone would also overcome the project’s biggest obstacle.
While most people at previous hearings expressed support for the footpaths, seating and other built elements in the design, the project’s landscaping is highly controversial.
Some people, anticipating the loss of the evergreens, are pushing for new oaks and elms that would one day reestablish a canopy of large trees.
Others, mostly those who live on the promenade and have views, are adamant that no new trees be planted.
Friends of the Eastern Promenade is proposing a compromise that will satisfy no one.
Their current plan calls for planting about two dozen ginkgo and hawthorn trees that will grow to 15 or 20 feet over the course of 20 years.
We should instead keep the evergreens and design the rest of the park’s landscaping to integrate them with its other features.
– Special to The Press Herald
Comments are no longer available on this story