5 min read

WINDHAM – The Maine Human Rights Commission on Monday sided with a Windham police officer in her claims of sexual harassment and retaliation, paving the way for a settlement.

Almost three years after the harassment started, Officer Danielle (Cyr) Nelson prevailed in her case against the town of Windham, with the five-member commission backing her charges that she was sexually harassed by a lower ranked officer and then retaliated against by fellow officers and superiors.

The 4-1 decision surprised Nelson’s lawyer, Rebecca Webber, who was amazed the commission not only ruled in favor of Nelson regarding the sexual harassment but also the retaliation, reversing the recommendation of the commission’s own investigator.

“I’m surprised because it’s very difficult to reverse an investigator, so to manage to do that makes me ecstatic,” said Webber, who won a suit against the city of Westbrook on behalf of two female firefighters several years ago. “And also the other part Danielle felt strongly about was the retaliation piece because she wants it to stop. I mean she wants it to work out so she can be a police officer for Windham, so we need to end that conduct so she can do that, because she really does want to go back to work and just work.”

After more than two years off the job, Nelson, an Auburn resident, went back to work last week just days before the commission was set to rule. She is in training for various re-certifications, her lawyer said.

Windham Town Manager Tony Plante, who did not want to comment last week due to the pending decision, commented on the matter after the vote Monday.

Advertisement

“We are disappointed with the commission’s ruling regarding retaliation, but never contested whether sexual harassment occurred,” Plante wrote in an email. “Once we became aware of the harassment, it was promptly investigated, and the alleged harasser’s employment was terminated. The department’s policies and practices have been improved and strengthened, and additional training has been provided. Officer (Cyr) Nelson recently returned to duty, a transition we expect to result in full resumption of her role as a patrol officer in the department soon, and hope that we can all put this behind us.”

According to Webber, Nelson also wants the matter behind her. Prior to last week’s return, Nelson had been on worker’s compensation since January 2010, Webber said. Webber praises the department for making some needed changes, as well, such as hiring a human resources manager and conducting sexual harassment training.

“A lot of workplaces have a lot of issues they have to work on,” Webber said. “And actually to Windham’s credit they’ve hired someone to take over HR functions, and that’s a very positive move, and someone came in to do training, too, which is also a sign of good faith and that they’re trying to make change.”

While changes have been made, Webber is hopeful when Nelson resumes patrolling duties and comes into contact with her fellow officers and supervisors, she will be warmly received. If not, Webber said, her life could be in peril since shunning by fellow officers could lead to dire results when responding to a call.

“Shunning, in context, can be very critical to basically sending a message, ‘Put up or shut up, don’t complain.’ For a police officer or firefighter, sending a message that you’re on your own is pretty scary because, really, your life depends on your not being alone and the fact that your fellow officers will risk their lives to make sure you’re not on your own,” Webber said. “But since she’s returned, she has been in training and not out in the field … but hopefully it will work out fine – that people will have learned from the whole experience and will now work together.”

Calls to police officer union representatives Matt Cyr and Jason Burke went unanswered this week and last week. Cyr declined to respond to the case last week.

Advertisement

NEXT STEPS

According to Maine law, Nelson had to first go through the Maine Human Rights Commission with her claim before she could choose to sue in court. The law allows plaintiffs to opt out of the commission process after 180 days if they so choose and forces the commission to vote on the matter within two years. Webber had Nelson stay engaged with the commission for what amounted to just shy of two years since Webber is a “believer in the process.”

“It’s helpful to hear what the investigator has to say and the members of the commission have to say about the case because it can educate you about strengths and weaknesses of your case and how an objective party would look at it, and that’s really important for trying to predict how a judge or jury would look at a case as well,” Webber explained.

While the commission has issued a ruling, the process is far from over. The next step is conciliation, which is a form of mediation where a commission representative acts as intermediary between the town’s attorney and Nelson’s attorney in order to reach a settlement. If a settlement can’t be reached, Nelson could sue the town in court.

The settlement, Webber said, would likely include monetary payment to Nelson “anywhere from a couple hundred dollars to a several hundred thousand dollars.” In the Westbrook firefighters case, the two firefighters received about $700,000 total.

Nelson’s settlement would likely be paid through the town’s insurance, as was recently done for Michael Denbow, a former Windham police sergeant who was fired in June 2010 after investigating a town councilor. Plante would not confirm whether a settlement in the Denbow case has been reached, although several sources, including Webber, confirm Denbow is no longer with the department and that a settlement has been reached using insurance. Since the matter was not settled in court, documents are not public record. Windham Police Chief Rick Lewsen said the town is not allowed to discuss Denbow’s case, according to terms of the settlement.

Also included in Nelson’s negotiated settlement, according to Webber, could be additional training for Windham personnel regarding discrimination and retaliation, discussion of who would supervise Nelson, or even installation of security cameras, as was the case in Westbrook.

Webber said she is hopeful Nelson can re-enter the workplace without further issues.

“Danielle really wants this to work out and have positive change come out of this. She really doesn’t want to be badmouthing her own officers in public because that would not be good for her and it wouldn’t be good for the department,” Webber said. “I think the bad part about litigation is that sometimes it’s the only way to get change to happen but then it does get people entrenched and upset and that’s not a good thing for getting people back on the right track working together.”

Comments are no longer available on this story