WASHINGTON —
The Supreme Court sounded prepared Tuesday to shield multinational corporations from being sued in the United States for allegedly violating human rights in other countries.
The justices heard arguments in a suit brought against the Royal Dutch Petroleum Co. by the Nigerian survivors of atrocities carried out by the Nigerian regime in the oil-rich delta region. The suit alleges that the Dutch oil company aided the Nigerian regime.
Justice Anthony M. Kennedy opened by stating that no nation in the world allows for suits against foreign corporations for actions that took place outside its territory. And he said he saw nothing in international law that authorized suits against corporations for violating human rights.
Several of Kennedy’s colleagues were quick to agree with his view. Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. wondered why the Nigerian case had gotten this far. “There’s no connection between these events and the United States,” he said.
Liberal Justices Elena Kagan and Stephen G. Breyer, however, said they saw nothing in international law that shielded corporations. But they appeared to be outvoted by the court’s five conservatives.
At issue was the reach of international human rights law and whether multinational corporations could be held liable for aiding foreign regimes that carry out atrocities, including murder, torture and enslavement. The justices appeared to agree that individuals could be held liable for violating human rights laws, but they disagreed over whether corporations could be sued as well.
Human rights lawyers have insisted these suits against multinational corporations are essential for preventing abuses and atrocities against native peoples.
Last year, however, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York rejected the suit against the Dutch oil company and ruled that American law does not authorize suits against corporations for alleged foreign violations of human rights law.
Los Angeles attorney Paul Hoffman, representing the Nigerian plaintiffs, said corporations should not be immune if they participate in atrocities. If, for example, a company “jointly operates torture centers” with a brutal regime, the company should be liable, he said.
But he ran into skeptical questioning from Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justice Antonin Scalia, as well as Kennedy and Alito. Along with Justice Clarence Thomas, they would have a majority to limit the reach of such suits.
However, a ruling rejecting corporate liability may not be the end of such claims. It is possible that future suits could target top corporate officials if their companies violate international law.
In a second case heard Tuesday, the justices signaled they will likely shield political organizations, such as the Palestinian Authority, from being sued for carrying out torture.
Comments are no longer available on this story