2 min read

Among solutions to important public policy issues, the most seductive, and the most deceptive, is the single-payer option Julie Pease advocates for health care (Another View, “Market reforms will not result in health care for all in Maine,” Jan. 30).

A model that would provide access to care for everyone without any personal financial constraint is irresistible. The problem, which Dr. Pease glosses over, is how to pay for this utopia.

Health care costs don’t go away just because a third party pays the bills; indeed, they’re likely to go up if demand increases, as it always does if a valuable product or service appears to be free or significantly undervalued. Third-party payers can only control supply in an effort to constrain costs, which in health care means cost controls on providers and rationing of care.

Social-welfare countries that have single-payer systems are all under varying degrees of financial stress because of rising health care costs, and many of them are turning to private market solutions for relief. The U.S. has its own single-payer systems in the form of Medicare and Medicaid, whose financial trajectories the programs’ own trustee says are unsustainable.

Insurance in Maine has been exorbitantly expensive because of onerous regulation that raised costs and eliminated most competition. Last year, the Legislature began taking steps to gradually undo some of the harmful effects of these misguided rules. A single-payer system that hides costs by shifting them from individuals to taxpayers would be a giant step back.

Dr. Pease disdains the benefits of competition and ignores the perverse incentives of a third-party payment system. She knows the patient is ill, but she doesn’t understand the causes and prescribes exactly the wrong treatment.

Martin Jones is a Freeport resident.

 

Comments are no longer available on this story