SOUTH PORTLAND – South Portland residents have made it clear during a series of meetings the last few weeks that they want a school budget that funds programs and resources to give students what they need to succeed.
At the same time, the City Council had given the Board of Education a directive to come up with a budget that did not increase taxes.
On Monday, April 25, at 7 p.m., the council is expected to weigh in on the school side of the proposed $69.2 million municipal budget, which includes $28 million in city spending and $38.1 million in school spending, as well as $1 million for the high school construction project and $2.1 million for Cumberland County.
The proposed spending plan is up slightly from the current budget of $27.2 in city spending, $37.4 in school spending, plus $507,000 for the high school construction project and $2 million for the county.
If approved as proposed, the municipal budget would call for $54 million from taxpayers – $1.4 million, or 2.72 percent, more than the current year. The tax rate would increase from $15.70 per $1,000 in valuation to $16.13, meaning a taxpayer with a home valued at $195,000 would expect to pay an additional $79.55.
Board of Education Chairman Ralph Baxter said the board took the council’s directive seriously, but felt it was important for the future of the district to provide the money needed to provide a quality education.
“We are continuing to advocate for our students,” Baxter said at a joint Board of Education and City Council meeting on April 6. “I believe what’s best for the city is best for the schools, and vice versa.”
During the last few years, the district has cut 49 positions, including the director of curriculum. Without that position, Superintendent Suzanne Godin said, the district has had trouble enriching the curriculum in the district.
“We are at the point where we are significantly impacting student achievement,” said Godin. “We are not able to provide in the areas we need to be providing.”
That issue is expected to be solved with the director of science, technology, engineering and math, a new position added for the 2011-2012 school year. Like others in the district, the position is funded through federal Jobs Bill money, or leftover funding from the American Reinvestment and Recovery Act, two sources of money that will not be available for the 2012-2013 school year.
Nearly everyone who spoke at the April 6 meeting was in favor of the increased budget for the school.
Investing in education, said Dara Saffer, is an investment in the community. Schools, she added, are not a business looking to make money, but rather a way to give children what they need for the future.
“Educating kids, whether we like it or not, is in our best interest,” she said. “We have to do it.”
Amy Turner, whose son Luke is in the fourth grade at Brown Elementary School, said it is important to have a quality education system in South Portland, not just for the students it serves, but the community as a whole.
“I learn through my son through what he learns at school and what he brings home to us,” Turner said, adding it is that type of experience that make South Portland a strong and desirable community.
Ross Little, a strong supporter of schools who said education is South Portland’s best civic asset, said it is time for all parties to get on the same page in funding education.
“We need to come together as a community and identify our priorities and figure out what we want our education to be given the resources we have,” Little said.
Justine Carlisle said she initially was supportive of a school budget that had no tax increase, especially after spending much of the fall knocking on doors asking residents to support a $42 million high school construction project.
However, after attending some school board workshop sessions and going through the superintendent’s proposed budget line by line, Carlisle said, she began seeing the need for a tax increase to support the educational budget.
“I do not support another year of a zero percent budget and another year of cuts,” she told members of the City Council, who were less willing to discuss whether they would support the tax increase in the school budget.
Councilor Tom Blake, who had four daughters go through the South Portland school system, said he was disappointed to see the cuts to the budget were aimed at staff and programming, rather than administrative overhead. He added that he was happy more money was going to maintenance, a priority in the city budget, as well. Blake said he supports the tax increase for the schools.
Councilors Patti Smith and Tom Coward said they are still undecided.
“In my opinion the zero percent was a stretch goal,” Coward said. “I said at the time, and I say it again, I am willing to consider something else.”
He said overall he is happy with the budget, but he needs to “drill into it a little more.”
Albert DiMillo, a frequent and vocal critic of school budgeting and spending (and an occasional columnist for The Current), was the only member of the public not in favor of what was presented. He said none of the numbers in the budget were correct. DiMillo, a retired corporate accountant, said through the last few years the district has erred in its planning, resulting in a surplus of money that was collected from the residents, but was never spent. DiMillo said because of poor budgeting and a reliance on faulty numbers year after year, the school district has a surplus of $4 million and does not need to increase taxes to fund its spending plan.
“I am telling you your numbers are wrong,” he told city officials. “Prove to me they are right.”
While the goal of the City Council and Board of Education is to work together to come up with an acceptable school budget, Mayor Rosemarie De Angelis said the two groups come into the process with different roles to play.
“The school (board’s) job is to do what’s best for the schools,” she said. “The council’s job is to decide how much money we can afford to give to the school but not actually make their decisions for them.”
Megan Gavin, of Thompson Street, said while she supports the budget as proposed, she does not support the process, which she called divisive. She said she would be interested in sitting down with board and council members to create a better process.
Resident Jeff Selser agreed that the process could be improved with more citizen participation, especially early on in the process. He suggested councilors reach out to the public prior to setting the school department’s bottom line so there could be a public discussion about what went well, what did not and what the priorities would be for funding.
“There are a lot of creative people out there and we want to lend our expertise and support, but we want to be consulted more,” he said.
Baxter said a new strategic planning committee might help the school district meet its future goals. The committee, he noted, is going to be formed over the next few months to focus on long-term strategies in terms of budgeting and education. The group would begin work in the fall.
Comments are no longer available on this story