One of the things I used to be thankful for was the presence of two sensible citizens representing me in the United States Senate.
Despite the fact that both Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins hurt my ears when they talk, at least they didn’t hurt my brain. I’m about as far from being a Republican as it’s possible to get, but Collins and Snowe were OK in my book: two smart women who knew that the truth is somewhere between the fringes.
But something has happened to the senator formerly known as moderate. Collins has, I think, slipped over the edge into No-No land.
Consider her stand on health care legislation. As far as I can tell, she’s against it. Once upon a time, I would have expected her to be against it because she believed the system we have now is perfectly fine and there’s no need to tamper with it. She would have been wrong, of course, but at least we could have understood.
Now she’s just against it, whatever it is. She says her job is to cut the cost of health care reform, which, at this point, is exactly what her job is not.
If we’re going to have a rational discussion of health care reform, don’t we first have to decide what we’re trying to accomplish? President Obama has said one goal should be to cover more people; another is to make sure people don’t lose existing insurance coverage. Senator Collins, along with the rest of her Republican colleagues, has not said whether she agrees with those goals, or any other goals.
It seems to me that the President and many (but not all) of the Democrats are trying to get some sort of insurance for people who don’t have any, while Senator Collins and some of her colleagues are trying to reduce insurance costs for people who already have it. One side is talking about how to bake an apple pie while the other is arguing about how to ride a bike.
A real Mainer, I think, would be telling the Congress that you have to know what you’re fishing for before you cut the bait. She’d be asking her colleagues to ask the question before they decide the answer. Once you agree on what you want to accomplish, you figure out how much it costs, and then you either do it or you say you can’t afford it and you don’t do it.
Senator Collins, on the other hand, seems to be saying, “Tell me what you need, and I’ll work to make certain you don’t have enough money to do the job.” I’m not a Mainer, except for living here, but that doesn’t sound like a Mainer’s solution to a problem.
Well, we’ll have plenty of time to discuss health care in this space, I suspect. I don’t know for sure what we’ll cover next time, except that I can assure you it will not be Sarah Palin, for which we can all be thankful.
Ray Clark lives in Gray.
Comments are no longer available on this story